Hall of Fame Tracker: Beltrán a Lock, Jones on the Brink, and Rising Stars
The Baseball Hall of Fame voting landscape is coming into sharper focus. While the official results won’t be revealed until January 20th on MLB Network, tools like Ryan Thibodaux’s Hall of Fame ballot tracker and Jason Sardell’s projections are offering valuable insights into how the Baseball Writers’ Association of America (BBWAA) vote is trending. Here’s a breakdown of the key takeaways as of Sunday, January 14th.
Beltrán’s Near Certainty
Carlos Beltrán appears poised for induction. Currently at 89.2% on the tracker, and projected for over 99.7% by Sardell’s simulations, Beltrán’s consistent performance across two decades – boasting over 500 doubles, 400 home runs, and 300 stolen bases – has resonated with voters. He joins an exclusive club alongside legends like Alex Rodríguez, Barry Bonds, Andre Dawson, and Willie Mays.
Andruw Jones: The Long Climb Nears Its Peak
The narrative surrounding Andruw Jones is one of the most compelling. After years of hovering below the threshold, his vote percentage has nearly doubled in the last five cycles, now sitting at 66.2%. While tracker percentages often slightly overestimate final results (Beltrán’s tracker percentage last year was 73.6%, final result 70.3%), Sardell’s simulations still give Jones a strong chance of election, clearing 75% in roughly three-quarters of scenarios. His 10 Gold Gloves and 434 home runs, coupled with a peak WAR comparable to Bonds and Rodríguez, are finally gaining the recognition they deserve.
Utley’s Momentum Builds
Chase Utley is experiencing a significant surge in support. At 66.5% in the tracker, this represents a massive leap from his 39.8% last year. While his final percentage is likely to settle in the low-to-mid 60s, Utley’s strong case – a career bWAR of 64.6 ranking 15th all-time among second basemen – and remaining eligibility on the ballot for seven more years position him well for future success.
Biggest Risers: Pitching Gains Traction
Beyond Utley, two pitchers are demonstrating the most significant gains. Félix Hernández has jumped from 20.6% to 57.0%, fueled by 30 new votes from returning BBWAA members. Similarly, Andy Pettitte has seen his support climb to 57.6%, gaining 22 new votes. Pettitte’s case is particularly interesting, as he’s in his eighth year on the ballot and mirroring the late-career surge experienced by Larry Walker before his eventual induction.
Did you know? Larry Walker’s vote percentage climbed steadily in his final years on the ballot, ultimately being elected in his tenth year – a trajectory Pettitte could potentially follow.
First-Timers and the 5% Threshold
This year’s ballot won’t see a first-time inductee. The key question is which newcomer will surpass the 5% threshold to remain eligible for future consideration. Currently, only Cole Hamels (32.3%) is above that line, a strong showing compared to the initial support received by Hernández and Pettitte in their first years. The remaining first-timers have garnered a combined total of just eight votes.
Facing Elimination: Ramirez and Hunter
Manny Ramirez, in his tenth and final year on the ballot, faces an uphill battle. Despite impressive offensive statistics (555 home runs, .312 average), his past PED controversies continue to hinder his chances. Torii Hunter is also in a precarious position, clinging to his candidacy at 4.4% in his sixth year. He narrowly cleared the 5% threshold last year, suggesting a close call is likely again.
Pro Tip: Understanding the BBWAA voting trends can help predict future Hall of Fame classes. Pay attention to players experiencing late-career surges and those gaining momentum in their early years on the ballot.
FAQ: Hall of Fame Voting
- What percentage is needed for Hall of Fame induction? 75% of the votes from the BBWAA.
- How long does a player remain on the ballot? A maximum of 10 years.
- What is the significance of the BBWAA ballot tracker? It provides a real-time snapshot of how the voting is progressing.
- Are simulations accurate predictors of the final results? Simulations offer valuable insights, but they are not foolproof. Actual voting can vary.
Explore more about baseball history and analysis on our Baseball Insights page. Don’t forget to subscribe to our newsletter for the latest updates and exclusive content!
