3 Charged After Toddler Undergoes Unnecessary Surgery in WV Proxy Case

Three adults face criminal charges in West Virginia following an investigation into medical child abuse that led to an unnecessary surgical procedure on a toddler, police said.

Detectives with the Monongalia County Sheriff’s Office opened the case after receiving concerns about a child’s medical history and the welfare of two minors living inside a Morgantown home, according to a news release issued by the department. Investigators found that the two-year-old child had attended about 175 doctor visits over a span of two years.

“repeatedly provided inaccurate and misleading information to medical professionals concerning one of the children's medical conditions and nutritional needs” Emilee Guzman, 29, said, according to the sheriff's office. Those misrepresentations contributed to the child undergoing the surgical placement of a gastrostomy tube on Oct. 1.

A child abuse pediatrician at WVU Medicine Children’s Hospital diagnosed the case as medical child abuse, commonly known as Munchausen syndrome by proxy, the sheriff’s office stated. “It’s the proxy; it’s mom’s actions that led to this unnecessary surgery,” Josh Ward of the Monongalia County Sheriff’s Office told local radio station WAJR.

3 charged in Munchausen by proxy case deputies say led to child’s unnecessary surgery in Mon County — WDTV 5 News

Charges Filed Against Morgantown Residents

Emilee Guzman is charged with one felony count of child neglect resulting in serious bodily injury. She is being held on a $75,000 bond with a preliminary hearing scheduled for Nov. 30.

Caitlin Jean Meredith, 32, and Milton Alexander Guzman Cisneros, 47, each face two counts of child neglect creating a risk of bodily injury. Both defendants are being held on a $25,000 bond.

Arrests
Photo: WTAE

Investigators executing a search warrant at the Morgantown residence uncovered hazardous and unsanitary living conditions alongside troubling treatment of the children in the household, deputies said. Foster caregivers later observed that the toddler consumed a wide variety of foods without significant difficulty and did not require the use of the G-tube after removal from Emilee Guzman’s custody.

Proposed Legislation Targeting Medical Child Abuse

State lawmakers in West Virginia plan to introduce a bill during the upcoming legislative session to establish a specific criminal offense for medical child abuse. Del. John Williams and Delegate-elect Olivia Miller announced the planned measure in response to the Monongalia County investigation.

“When kids in West Virginia are abused, we have to step up and be there for them. Medical child abuse is far more common than people realize, and we need a clear statute that will allow us to go after those who do harm to our kids,” said Del. John Williams.

3 charged in Munchausen by proxy case deputies say led to child’s unnecessary surgery in Mon Coun… — WDTV 5 News

“We will protect West Virginia's children and hold those who abuse them accountable,” said Delegate-elect Olivia Miller.

Common Questions About the Monongalia County Case

What specific charges do the defendants face?

Emilee Guzman faces one felony count of child neglect resulting in serious bodily injury. Caitlin Jean Meredith and Milton Alexander Guzman Cisneros each face two counts of child neglect creating a risk of bodily injury.

3 Charged After Toddler Undergoes Unnecessary Surgery in WV Proxy Case
Photo: Yahoo

How many medical appointments did the toddler attend?

Investigators reviewing extensive medical records determined that the two-year-old child had attended about 175 doctor visits in just over two years.

What medical procedure did the child undergo?

The child underwent the surgical placement of a gastrostomy tube on Oct. 1 after inaccurate information regarding nutritional needs was provided to medical professionals.

When is the next scheduled court appearance?

Emilee Guzman has a preliminary hearing scheduled for Nov. 30, while neither Meredith nor Guzman Cisneros has upcoming court dates listed in their records.