Cardinals’ Rebuild: Beyond May, What’s Next for Donovan, Romero & Arenado?
The St. Louis Cardinals recently added pitcher Dustin May, a move signaling activity but hinting at something larger brewing within the organization. While May’s acquisition is interesting – and comes with inherent risk given his injury history – the real story lies in who *else* might be on the move as the Cardinals embark on a significant rebuild. The team has reportedly been discussing trades involving several key players, and the next few weeks could dramatically reshape their roster.
The Pieces in Play: A Closer Look
Brendan Donovan, JoJo Romero, Nolan Arenado, and Willson Contreras have all been subjects of trade discussions. However, it’s the rising value of left-handed reliever JoJo Romero that’s generating the most buzz. His performance in 2025 – a 2.07 ERA in 65 appearances, coupled with exceptional metrics in exit velocity, hard-hit rate, and ground-ball rate – has made him a highly sought-after commodity. Teams are particularly impressed with his ability to neutralize opposing hitters, as evidenced by his success against Shohei Ohtani.
Arenado and Contreras bring established star power, but their contracts are larger and potentially less appealing to teams looking for long-term flexibility. Donovan, a versatile infielder, offers value but may not command the same return as Romero. Even players like Nolan Gorman, Lars Nootbaar, and Pedro Pagés could become trade chips as the Cardinals prioritize future assets.
The Reliever Market & The Value of Dominant Lefty Specialists
Romero’s situation highlights a growing trend in MLB: the premium placed on dominant, late-inning relievers. Teams are increasingly recognizing the importance of a shutdown bullpen, and are willing to pay a high price for pitchers who can consistently get crucial outs. Consider the recent trade for Josh Hader, who commanded a significant package of prospects. Romero, with his wipeout slider and impressive statistics, fits that mold perfectly.
Pro Tip: When evaluating reliever trades, don’t just look at ERA. Metrics like FIP (Fielding Independent Pitching) and xFIP (expected FIP) provide a more accurate picture of a pitcher’s underlying skill, independent of defensive performance.
May’s Acquisition: Risk and Reward
Dustin May’s $12 million contract (with a $20 million option for 2027) represents a calculated gamble for the Cardinals. His talent is undeniable, but his injury history is concerning. Tommy John surgeries in 2021 and 2023, and a life-threatening esophageal tear in 2024, raise serious questions about his long-term durability. The Cardinals are betting that they can unlock May’s potential, but they’re also aware of the risks involved.
This acquisition mirrors a trend of teams taking chances on high-upside players with medical concerns, hoping to capitalize on their potential if they can stay healthy. The upside is significant, but the downside – a wasted investment – is also real.
The Rebuild Timeline: How Trades Shape the Future
The Cardinals’ rebuild isn’t simply about shedding salary; it’s about acquiring young talent and building a sustainable contender. The trades they make in the coming weeks will dictate the speed of that process. A haul of top prospects could accelerate the timeline, while a series of underwhelming returns could prolong the rebuilding phase.
Did you know? The Chicago Cubs’ rapid rebuild, spearheaded by President of Baseball Operations Jed Hoyer, demonstrates the power of acquiring and developing young talent through strategic trades and draft picks. They went from a struggling franchise to a playoff contender in just a few years.
FAQ: Cardinals Trade Rumors
- Will Nolan Arenado be traded? It’s possible, but his contract makes it more challenging.
- What is JoJo Romero’s trade value? Very high, given his recent performance and the demand for elite relievers.
- How long will the Cardinals’ rebuild take? That depends on the quality of the prospects they acquire. A realistic timeline is 3-5 years.
- Is Dustin May a good addition despite his injuries? He has high potential, but carries significant risk.
The Cardinals are at a crossroads. The decisions they make now will define their future for years to come. Fans are understandably anxious, but the potential for a brighter tomorrow is within reach – provided the team executes its rebuild strategy effectively.
Want to stay up-to-date on the latest Cardinals news and MLB trade rumors? Subscribe to our newsletter for exclusive insights and analysis!
