A proposed hotel development in Niagara-on-the-Lake, Ontario, is facing scrutiny from local residents concerned about its potential impact and the handling of the project by both the developer and the town. The Parliament Oak Hotel, planned for the site of a former school at 325 King St., is located a few hundred metres from the town’s main tourist area.
Concerns Over Flooding and Bylaw Infractions
Developer Two Sisters Resorts intends to build a four-storey facility with 130 suites, event space, a restaurant, bar, and green space. However, the project has been plagued by multiple bylaw infractions, and residents fear the construction could lead to flooding. Ron Simkus, a retired engineer, and a group of local experts have analyzed the developer’s plans and expressed concerns about the scale of the project and its potential to divert underground water into nearby One Mile Creek, which borders approximately 90 homes.
Despite these concerns, Niagara-on-the-Lake Lord Mayor Gary Zalepa stated that town staff have reviewed the plans and have no concerns about the project. He expressed confidence that a satisfactory outcome has been reached.
Development Charge Waiver Sparks Controversy
Further fueling resident frustration, regional councillors recently voted to waive $904,819 in development charges for the project on November 20th. Development charges are typically used to fund infrastructure improvements needed to support new development. A lawyer representing Two Sisters Resorts argued the waiver was justified because the town required the developer to build an additional level of underground parking not originally planned.
Simkus and other residents argue the developer should have anticipated the need for additional parking based on earlier site plans. Zalepa, who voted in favour of the waiver, believes that charging development fees for underground parking could discourage developers from including it in their projects, despite the region’s efforts to encourage such construction. Some regional councillors have questioned whether the waived fees will ultimately be covered by Niagara taxpayers, with staff expected to report on the financial implications.
Call for Investigation
On December 20th, the Niagara-on-the-Lake Residents Association sent a letter to Ontario’s ombudsman alleging that the regional council’s decision was based on “misinformation” and “improper considerations” and exceeded its authority. The ombudsman’s office has acknowledged receipt of the letter but has not commented further due to its confidential complaints process. As of December 22nd, Zalepa stated he had not yet seen the complaint.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the Parliament Oak Hotel planned to include?
The Parliament Oak Hotel, as proposed by Two Sisters Resorts, will include 130 suites, event space, a restaurant, a bar, and green space.
How many fines has the developer received from the town?
As of December 18th, the town of Niagara-on-the-Lake had fined the developer $500 a total of 10 times.
What amount of development charges were waived for the project?
Regional councillors voted to waive $904,819 in development charges for the Parliament Oak Hotel project.
As construction progresses, it remains to be seen how the concerns of residents will be addressed and whether the project will proceed as planned. A possible next step could be a response from the Ombudsman’s office regarding the complaint filed by the Residents Association. Further scrutiny of the financial implications of the development charge waiver is also likely, and the town may need to address ongoing concerns about bylaw compliance.
Related reading