From Backup to Super Bowl? The Rise of the ‘Next Man Up’ Quarterback
The Denver Broncos find themselves in an unexpected position heading into the AFC Championship Game: relying on Jarrett Stidham, a quarterback with limited starting experience, to lead them to the Super Bowl. This situation isn’t unique. Across the NFL, teams are increasingly forced to navigate critical games with backup quarterbacks due to injuries, performance issues, or unforeseen circumstances. But what does this trend signify for the future of the league, and how are teams preparing for this new reality?
The Increasing Prevalence of Backup QB Reliance
Historically, the backup quarterback was often seen as a placeholder, a game manager expected to minimize damage while the starter recovered. Today, that role is evolving. Injuries to key players like Bo Nix highlight the fragility of the position. According to data from Spotrac, quarterback injuries have risen by 18% over the last five seasons, forcing teams to lean on their depth more than ever before. This isn’t just about injury rates; it’s also about the modern, physically demanding nature of the game.
The Broncos’ situation with Stidham is a prime example. He’s started only four games in his career, all at the tail end of losing seasons. Now, he’s thrust into a championship game. His success, or lack thereof, will undoubtedly influence how teams evaluate and invest in backup quarterback talent.
The Evolution of Backup QB Evaluation & Development
Teams are no longer content with simply drafting or signing a veteran to hold a clipboard. We’re seeing a shift towards prioritizing quarterbacks with specific skillsets – those who can quickly grasp a playbook, exhibit poise under pressure, and possess a level of athleticism that allows them to execute a diverse range of plays.
The San Francisco 49ers, with Brock Purdy’s unexpected success after injuries to Trey Lance and Jimmy Garoppolo, are a case study in this. Purdy, a “Mr. Irrelevant” draft pick, demonstrated the value of a quarterback who understands the system and can make quick decisions. This has led to teams actively seeking quarterbacks who are ‘system fits’ even if they lack elite physical traits.
Pro Tip: When evaluating backup quarterbacks, look beyond arm strength and focus on decision-making, accuracy in short-to-intermediate throws, and the ability to protect the football.
The Impact on Offensive Scheme Design
The rise of the ‘next man up’ quarterback is also influencing offensive scheme design. Teams are increasingly adopting more streamlined, adaptable playbooks that don’t rely on a quarterback possessing a unique set of skills. The emphasis is shifting towards creating opportunities for playmakers and utilizing pre-snap reads and quick passing concepts.
Sean Payton, the Broncos’ head coach, is known for his ability to tailor offenses to his quarterback’s strengths. His confidence in Stidham suggests he believes the existing system can be effectively executed, regardless of who’s under center. This is a trend we’ll likely see continue – coaches designing offenses that are quarterback-friendly rather than quarterback-dependent.
The Financial Implications: Investing in Depth
Historically, backup quarterbacks were often signed to inexpensive, one-year deals. However, the increasing importance of the position is driving up salaries. Teams are now willing to invest more in quality backups, recognizing the potential cost of losing games due to inadequate depth.
Consider the recent contract extensions given to quarterbacks like Cooper Rush (Dallas Cowboys) and Gardner Minshew (Indianapolis Colts). These players aren’t expected to be long-term starters, but they are valued for their ability to provide stability and win games when called upon. This trend will likely continue, with teams prioritizing financial flexibility to secure reliable backup options.
The Role of Analytics in Backup QB Selection
Advanced analytics are playing a growing role in evaluating backup quarterbacks. Metrics like completion percentage under pressure, time to throw, and sack avoidance are becoming increasingly important. Teams are using data to identify quarterbacks who can minimize mistakes and maximize efficiency, even in challenging situations.
Did you know? Teams are now using virtual reality simulations to assess how backup quarterbacks react to different game scenarios, providing valuable insights into their decision-making process.
FAQ
Q: Is the backup quarterback position becoming more important than ever?
A: Absolutely. Increased injury rates and the complexity of modern offenses mean teams can’t afford to have a significant drop-off in performance when the starter goes down.
Q: What qualities should teams look for in a backup quarterback?
A: Decision-making, accuracy, poise under pressure, and a quick understanding of the playbook are crucial.
Q: Will we see more teams drafting quarterbacks specifically to be backups?
A: It’s likely. Teams are recognizing the value of developing quarterbacks within their system who are prepared to step in when needed.
Want to learn more about NFL quarterback strategies? Explore our in-depth analysis here. Don’t forget to subscribe to our newsletter for the latest NFL insights and analysis!
