Sir Keir Starmer has defended the Labour Party’s decision to prevent Andy Burnham from contesting an upcoming by-election in Gorton and Denton. The move has sparked internal disagreement within the party, raising questions about unity and strategic priorities ahead of crucial elections in May.
A Blocked Candidacy
Burnham, currently the Mayor of Greater Manchester and a former minister, was widely viewed as a potential future leadership challenger to Sir Keir should he return to Westminster. The Labour Party’s National Executive Committee (NEC), which includes Sir Keir, blocked his candidacy, stating the decision would “avoid an unnecessary mayoral election.”
However, the decision has not been without opposition. Some Labour backbenchers have voiced concerns over what they describe as “petty factional manoeuvring” and are calling for a reconsideration of the NEC’s ruling.
Strategic Concerns and Resource Allocation
Sir Keir Starmer justified the decision by arguing that allowing Burnham to run for a Westminster seat would “divert our resources” from critical upcoming elections. These include elections in Wales’ Senedd, the Scottish parliament, and English local elections, where Labour faces potential setbacks. He emphasized the party’s focus on campaigning on the cost of living crisis.
“Resources, whether that’s money or people, need to be focused on the elections that we must have, not elections that we don’t have to have,” Sir Keir stated, explaining the rationale behind the NEC’s decision. He also highlighted his past support for Burnham’s 2015 leadership bid and their ongoing collaboration on projects like the Northern Powerhouse Rail.
Burnham’s Response and Internal Divisions
Burnham, when questioned by the BBC, declined to comment directly on the decision, stating he was focused on his role as Mayor of Greater Manchester. He did, however, invite Labour MPs to “come up to Manchester” to assist with the upcoming by-election campaign, emphasizing a spirit of “togetherness.”
The decision has exposed fractures within the Labour Party. While a majority of Labour politicians, approximately two to one, reportedly support the NEC’s decision, concerns remain about the potential long-term consequences. Some MPs fear the move could backfire, while others question Burnham’s level of support within the Parliamentary Labour Party.
What Happens Next?
The by-election in Gorton and Denton is now scheduled to likely be held on Thursday, February 26th. Labour will need to quickly rally around a new candidate. It is possible that the internal debate over this decision could continue to simmer, potentially impacting party morale in the lead-up to the May elections. Depending on the results of those elections, the pressure on Sir Keir’s leadership could increase, potentially opening the door for future leadership challenges – though whether Burnham would mount one remains unclear.
Frequently Asked Questions
What was the reason given for blocking Andy Burnham from running in the by-election?
The Labour Party’s National Executive Committee stated the block was to “avoid an unnecessary mayoral election” and to focus resources on upcoming elections in May.
Did Andy Burnham comment on the decision?
Burnham stated he was not making any comment and reiterated his focus on his role as Mayor of Greater Manchester.
Is there disagreement within the Labour Party about this decision?
Yes, some Labour backbenchers have complained about “petty factional manoeuvring” and are calling for the decision to be reconsidered, while others support the NEC’s decision.
Given the internal divisions and the strategic stakes involved, how will this decision ultimately impact Labour’s performance in the upcoming elections?
