The Twilight of TV Comebacks: When Nostalgia Fails
The recent dust-up surrounding the Dutch TV show Ranking the Stars, featuring Paul de Leeuw and Patty Brard, highlights a growing trend: the diminishing returns of reviving once-popular formats. What was once a clever game show is now, according to many, a shadow of its former self, propped up by reality TV personalities and generating controversy rather than genuine entertainment.
The Problem with Rebooting
The entertainment landscape has drastically changed since Ranking the Stars first aired in 2006. The proliferation of streaming services, the rise of social media, and a fragmented audience signify that simply bringing back a familiar name isn’t enough to guarantee success. As Tina Nijkamp pointed out, the show feels more suited to platforms like Videoland or RTL 5, suggesting it no longer holds the same appeal for a broad, mainstream audience.
The core issue isn’t necessarily the format itself, but the context. Audiences are more discerning and have access to a wider range of content. A show that relied on novelty and celebrity appeal two decades ago now needs a compelling reason to exist in a saturated market. Simply relying on nostalgia, as Ranking the Stars appears to be doing, is often insufficient.
The Patty Brard Defense: A Sign of the Times?
Patty Brard’s defensive reaction on Shownieuws – her insistence that viewers who don’t enjoy the show should simply “turn it off” – is telling. It reveals a disconnect between the show’s creators and the critical reception. Her passionate defense of Paul de Leeuw and the show’s entertainment value feels increasingly out of touch with a public that is quick to voice its opinions online and has little patience for perceived mediocrity.
Brard’s argument that the show performs well on catch-up services like Videoland suggests a shift in viewing habits. While initial linear TV ratings may be modest, the show finds a second life through on-demand platforms. This raises questions about the future of traditional television and the viability of shows designed primarily for delayed viewing.
The Reality TV Factor: Diluting the Brand
The inclusion of reality TV figures like Sjorleone is a key point of contention. While these personalities may attract a certain demographic, they also risk alienating viewers who associate Ranking the Stars with a different kind of celebrity. The show’s descent into “reality vodjes,” as described in the article, signals a compromise of its original identity.
This trend reflects a broader pattern in television: the increasing blurring of lines between different genres. Reality TV has become a dominant force, and its influence is seeping into other formats, often to the detriment of their quality and originality.
What Does This Mean for TV Revivals?
The case of Ranking the Stars serves as a cautionary tale for anyone considering a TV revival. Success requires more than just a recognizable title and familiar faces. It demands a fresh perspective, a compelling narrative, and a clear understanding of the current media landscape.
Producers need to ask themselves: What does this show offer that viewers can’t find elsewhere? Is it relevant to today’s audiences? And is it worth sacrificing the show’s original identity in pursuit of short-term gains?
FAQ
Q: Is Ranking the Stars cancelled?
A: There is no information available to confirm if the show is cancelled, but the critical reception suggests its future is uncertain.
Q: Who is Paul de Leeuw?
A: Paul de Leeuw is a Dutch television presenter and comedian, and the host of Ranking the Stars.
Q: What is the criticism of the show?
A: Critics argue that the show has become outdated, relies too heavily on reality TV personalities, and lacks the originality of its earlier seasons.
Q: Where can I watch Ranking the Stars?
A: The show airs on RTL 4 and is also available on catch-up services like Videoland.
Did you know? Patty Brard has been a consistent panel member throughout many seasons of Ranking the Stars, appearing in 43 episodes as of February 7, 2026.
Pro Tip: Before investing in a TV revival, conduct thorough market research to gauge audience interest and identify potential pitfalls.
What are your thoughts on TV revivals? Share your opinions in the comments below!
