The Ripple Effect: Family, Identity, and the Shifting Landscape of Motherhood on Stage
Water, as a metaphor, is having a moment in contemporary theatre. Phanésia Pharel’s new play, The Waterfall, currently running at Off-Broadway’s WP Theater in a co-production with Thrown Stone Theatre Company, dives deep into this symbolism, exploring the complex currents of family, identity, and the often-fraught relationship between mothers and daughters. The play, running through March 1, resonates with a broader cultural conversation about womanhood and the choices women make – or feel pressured to make – about motherhood.
A Generational Divide Rooted in Experience
At the heart of The Waterfall lies the dynamic between Emiliene (Emi), a Haiti-born matriarch, and her Haitian American daughter, Bean. Emi’s connection to a waterfall in her hometown of Croix-des-Bouquets is spiritual and deeply ingrained, while Bean remains skeptical, having never experienced Haiti firsthand. This physical and emotional distance mirrors a larger generational gap in perspectives on life, duty, and the American Dream. The play doesn’t shy away from the tension that arises when a mother’s vision for her child clashes with the child’s own aspirations.
Pharel’s inspiration stems from her own family history and a desire to honor the experiences of women. The playwright’s mother, like many immigrants, carried a strong belief in providing a better life for her children, often with a preconceived notion of what that life should look like. This creates a central conflict: what does it imply to reach to a new country and then impose a vision on the next generation?
The Taboo of Motherhood Regret
The Waterfall bravely tackles a subject often whispered about in private: the possibility of regretting motherhood. Pharel was influenced by Israeli sociologist Orna Donath’s Regretting Motherhood, which shares accounts of women who grapple with the emotional and societal pressures of parenthood. The play explores how external forces, such as racism and trauma, can disrupt the idealized image of motherhood, and how these experiences shape a daughter’s perspective.
Bean’s firm stance against having children is not presented as rebellion, but as a conscious decision rooted in a deep understanding of her own desires and limitations. Her poignant lines – “If I had a bad mother maybe I would be able to stomp out this feeling / And blame it on her / But I had the best mother / That’s how I understand / I’m not supposed to be a mother” – encapsulate the play’s central theme: the freedom to choose one’s own path, even if it diverges from familial expectations.
Demographic Shifts and Cultural Context
The play’s themes are particularly resonant in light of current demographic trends. While the U.S. Birth rate has fallen to record lows, Haiti faces the opposite challenge of overpopulation. This contrast highlights the differing realities and pressures faced by Emi and Bean, and underscores the complexities of identity and belonging. The play doesn’t offer easy answers, but instead invites audiences to grapple with these tough questions.
Director Taylor Reynolds emphasizes the importance of immersing herself in Haitian culture and understanding the nuances of the immigrant experience. She highlights the power of storytelling to bridge cultural divides and foster empathy.
The Power of Representation and Cultural Work
Reynolds, known for her work with Movement Theatre Company, prioritizes stories of Black women and those from Caribbean and West African descent. This commitment to representation is crucial in a theatre landscape that has historically marginalized diverse voices. The Waterfall is not just a play about a mother and daughter. it’s a testament to the power of cultural work to illuminate complex experiences and challenge societal norms.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Where can I notice The Waterfall?
A: The Waterfall is playing at WP Theater in New York City through March 1, 2026.
Q: Who wrote The Waterfall?
A: The play was written by Phanésia Pharel.
Q: What are the main themes of the play?
A: The play explores themes of family, identity, motherhood, generational divides, and the immigrant experience.
Q: Is the play based on a true story?
A: While not directly autobiographical, the play is inspired by the playwright’s own family history and experiences.
Did you know? The word “Dessources,” the surname of Pharel’s grandmother, translates to “from the springs” or “from the source” in English, further emphasizing the play’s central metaphor of water.
Explore more thought-provoking theatre and cultural commentary on our website. Share your thoughts on The Waterfall in the comments below!
