Buffalo Bills Free Agency: Prioritizing Needs and Value in 2026
Free agency is rapid approaching, and the Buffalo Bills have holes across the roster. From spots that demand patching up to areas in need of a complete overhaul, the 2026 Bills will look completely different. While marquee signings may be limited, a deep pool of useful players exists, offering essential personnel to target. Here’s a look at players who could significantly impact Buffalo’s success.
Addressing the Secondary: Bryan Cook, Safety
The Bills’ safety situation in 2025 was a patchwork of veterans and developing players. While Jordan Poyer provided experience, a more consistent presence is needed. Kansas City Chiefs safety Bryan Cook offers that stability.
Cook is coming off a career year with the Chiefs, totaling 85 tackles and 6 passes defensed. He’s an ideal free safety to pair with Cole Bishop’s physical playstyle. A dynamic duo in the back third of the field would elevate Jim Leonhard’s defense. He’s projected to command close to $15m per season, a significant investment, but potentially worthwhile if safety is a top priority.
Linebacker Reinforcements: Alex Anzalone
Effective linebackers are crucial for Jim Leonhard’s defensive scheme. While Terrel Bernard is expected to start, bolstering the outside linebacker positions is essential. Lions linebacker Alex Anzalone presents a viable option.
At 31, Anzalone is a veteran presence as the Bills develop younger players. His production remains strong, and he’s estimated to cost around $7.3m, making him an affordable and impactful addition.
Wide Receiver Options: Hopkins and Lockett
The 2026 free agent receiver class lacks top-tier talent. Yet, veteran options offer value and experience. Two names stand out: DeAndre Hopkins and Tyler Lockett.
DeAndre Hopkins: A Proven Veteran
DeAndre Hopkins has been linked to the Bills for years. While no longer in his prime, he can replicate Brandin Cooks’ contributions. A full offseason with Josh Allen could significantly elevate the offense, and his contract won’t cripple the Bills’ spending, estimated at a manageable figure.
Tyler Lockett: Affordable Consistency
Tyler Lockett offers consistency and reliable hands. Despite a quiet 2025 season with the Titans and Raiders, he possesses the field IQ to help develop younger receivers. He’s expected to cost under $2m, making him a bargain.
Edge Rusher Depth: Haason Reddick
Buffalo needs to address its edge rusher situation after a lackluster performance from some veterans. Haason Reddick offers a cost-effective solution. While he’s past his peak, he’s still productive and won’t break the bank.
In a market where top pass rushers command high salaries, securing Reddick early is a smart move. He’s projected to be more affordable than players like Hendrickson, Oweh, and Mack, and can contribute to the latest defensive scheme.
Offensive Line Stability: Evan Neal
The Bills face potential departures at both left guard and center. Evan Neal, a versatile guard, could fill a crucial role. He can play both sides of the line and fits the Bills’ run game scheme. Finishing his rookie deal, he’s projected to cost around $4.4m per season.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Will the Bills overspend in free agency?
A: The Bills will likely prioritize value and fit over pursuing high-profile, expensive players.
Q: What position is the biggest need for the Bills?
A: Safety and wide receiver are key areas of need, but addressing the offensive line and linebacker positions are too important.
Q: Are the Bills likely to make any blockbuster signings?
A: It’s unlikely, given the team’s financial situation and the lack of truly elite free agents.
Did you know? The Bills’ success in free agency will depend on identifying players who fit their scheme and culture, not just those with the biggest names.
Pro Tip: Retain an eye on players who have thrived in similar defensive schemes to Jim Leonhard’s. Their transition to Buffalo will be smoother.
What do you think? Which free agent would you like to witness the Bills sign? Share your thoughts in the comments below!
