Barcelona vs. New York: A Surprising Retail Landscape
While Benidorm officially holds the nickname ‘the New York of the Mediterranean’, Barcelona consistently draws comparisons to the American metropolis. This isn’t necessarily a reflection of reality, but rather a cultural and economic aspiration rooted in a curious similarity: Manhattan and Barcelona share almost identical populations and commercial grid sizes.
A recent study by Observatori Eixos, led by David Nogué, examined this parallel. Commissioned by US administrations in 2019 and 2025, the research compared the commercial ecosystems of both cities to enrich the debate surrounding local commerce.
More Shops, Different Structures
The study revealed a striking difference: Barcelona boasts twice as many commercial establishments as New York City. Barcelona has approximately 76,000 locales, with 62,000 actively operating businesses, compared to Manhattan’s 30,000 spaces and 27,000 operational establishments. Expanding the scope to their respective metropolitan areas further accentuates this gap: around 153,000 active locales in the province of Barcelona versus 68,000 in the Hudson Valley.
However, this isn’t the whole story. Barcelona has a higher number of vacant premises than New York, and New York properties tend to be larger due to the demands of established brands. Different urban planning approaches and lifestyles in the US and Southern Europe also play a significant role.
The Rise of Proximity Commerce
The study highlights the importance of local commerce. David Nogué notes that in the Llobregat Valley, residents have ample opportunities to walk to shops for everyday needs, a convenience less common in the Hudson Valley, where reliance on cars and delivery services like Amazon is more prevalent.
Despite the higher number of shops, both cities demonstrate a strong recovery in commercial activity post-pandemic, with high occupancy rates.
Comparing Commercial Sectors
Looking at business types, both Barcelona and Manhattan have a similar number of restaurants – over 2,500 each – and comparable numbers of cafes. However, Barcelona has significantly more bars (5,700 versus 1,400 in Manhattan).
Barcelona also stands out with 39 municipal markets, while New York City has only one, the Essex Market. Eixos found Barcelona has ten times more butcher shops and fishmongers, and 43% more grocery stores.
Conversely, New York City has more shopping malls, galleries, and department stores (41) compared to Barcelona (30), and the Hudson Valley boasts 224, while the Barcelona province has 62.
Eixos, Grids, and Corridors
The study identified three primary types of commercial axes: street-based axes with connecting side streets, homogeneous grid-based areas, and “corridors” – major roads lined with businesses. Barcelona’s Eixample district, with 1,000 establishments per square kilometer, mirrors Manhattan’s grid structure (700 per square kilometer). The Eixample in El Prat de Llobregat (400 per square kilometer) and the southern Bronx (200 per square kilometer) were also noted for their similarities.
A significant commercial corridor in the Barcelona area stretches from Molins de Rei to Port Vell, encompassing 1,825 businesses along the Paral·lel, Sants road, and N-340. A comparable corridor in the US runs between Ramapo and Clarkstown, with 929 businesses.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Does this study suggest Barcelona is a better place to shop than New York?
A: Not necessarily. The study highlights differences in structure and density, not quality. Both cities offer diverse retail experiences.
Q: What is the significance of the commercial corridors identified in the study?
A: These corridors represent potential areas for economic development and improved accessibility to local businesses.
Q: How did the pandemic impact commercial activity in both cities?
A: Both cities experienced setbacks, but have since shown strong recovery in occupancy rates.
Q: What is the Eixample district in Barcelona?
A: The Eixample is a district in Barcelona known for its grid-like urban plan and high concentration of commercial establishments.
Did you understand? Barcelona has nearly double the number of commercial establishments compared to New York City, despite having a similar population.
Pro Tip: When exploring Barcelona, venture beyond the main tourist areas to discover the vibrant local shops and markets.
Explore more articles on urban planning and economic development here.
