The Rise of Private Security at US Airports: A Growing Trend?
Although many US travelers are experiencing longer-than-usual security lines due to staffing issues at the Transportation Security Administration (TSA), a surprising number of airports are bypassing these delays altogether. In 20 airports across the United States, security screening isn’t handled by the TSA, but by private companies. And, crucially, these checkpoints aren’t seeing the same backups.
The TSA’s Screening Partnership Program (SPP)
Airports like San Francisco International, Kansas City International and Orlando Sanford are participants in the TSA’s Screening Partnership Program (SPP). This program allows airports to outsource security screening to certified private contractors. While the TSA still manages and supervises all procedures, the actual screening is performed by companies like Covenant Aviation Security and BOS Security.
These private companies have proven more resilient to staffing shortages that are currently plaguing some TSA-staffed airports, particularly during the ongoing government funding impasse. “These 20 airports are totally unaffected by the government shutdown,” explains Sheldon Jacobson, a computer science professor who analyzes data to improve air travel security.
VMD Corp., which manages checkpoints at Kansas City and Orlando Sanford, highlighted their efficiency on social media, stating their SPP airports are experiencing wait times of under three minutes.
Why Private Security is Different
A key difference lies in employment stability. While TSA employees have been working without pay for over a month due to the government shutdown, private contractors continue to receive their salaries. Nat Carmack, of BOS Security, which handles passenger screening at Tupelo Regional Airport in Mississippi, stated, “All operations at privatized airports are running normally as we continue to pay our employees during the shutdown. Our employees have never missed a paycheck during any government closures.”
Carmack acknowledges that covering payroll during a shutdown is a financial burden for the company, but they prioritize maintaining staffing levels until the government resumes operations and settles outstanding invoices.
Though, it’s important to note that even with private contractors, security standards remain federally mandated. Keith Jeffries, former TSA Federal Security Director for Los Angeles International Airport and current VP of K2 Security Screening Group, emphasizes that private screeners receive the same training as TSA agents. “In the private sector, one doesn’t set the standards,” Jacobson explains. “What one does in the private sector is deliver the final product.”
The Challenges of Switching to Private Security
Despite the benefits, transitioning to private security isn’t a quick fix for airports struggling with TSA staffing. Airports must first obtain permission from the TSA, and the contracting process can take up to a year. This lengthy timeline and bureaucratic hurdles may discourage larger airports from pursuing this option, opting for a “if it ain’t broke, don’t fix it” approach.
BOS Security points to studies suggesting that private contractors are more effective at detecting contraband, are more cost-effective, and have higher employee satisfaction rates. However, the American Federation of Government Employees (AFGE), the union representing TSA screeners, argues that these contracts – often awarded to the lowest bidder – compromise public safety, incentivize companies to prioritize profits over passenger and employee well-being, and contribute to staffing shortages.
The AFGE also points out that, prior to the September 11, 2001 terrorist attacks, all airport security in the United States was managed by private companies.
A Seem at Airports Utilizing Private Security
Here’s a list of the 20 airports currently utilizing the TSA’s Screening Partnership Program:
- Aeropuerto Internacional de Atlantic City, Nueva Jersey
- Aeropuerto del Condado de Sonoma–Charles M. Schulz, California
- Aeropuerto Comunitario de Dawson, Montana
- Aeropuerto Internacional de Great Falls, Montana
- Aeropuerto Internacional Glacier Park, Montana
- Aeropuerto Internacional de Greater Rochester, Nueva York
- Aeropuerto de la Ciudad y el Condado de Havre, Montana
- Aeropuerto Internacional de Kansas City, Missouri
- Aeropuerto L. M. Clayton, Montana
- Aeropuerto Internacional de Orlando Sanford, Florida
- Aeropuerto Internacional de Portsmouth, Nueva Hampshire
- Aeropuerto de Punta Gorda, Florida
- Centro Aéreo Internacional de Roswell; Nuevo México
- Aeropuerto Internacional de San Francisco, California
- Aeropuerto Internacional de Sarasota-Bradenton, Florida
- Aeropuerto Municipal de Sidney-Richland, Montana
- Aeropuerto Regional de Sioux Falls, Dakota del Sur
- Aeropuerto Regional de Tupelo, Mississippi
- Wokal Field/Aeropuerto Internacional de Glasgow, Montana
- Aeropuerto de Yellowstone, Montana
Future Trends: A Hybrid Approach?
The current situation highlights a potential future trend: a hybrid approach to airport security. Rather than a complete shift to private security, we may see increased collaboration between the TSA and private contractors, leveraging the strengths of both. This could involve expanding the SPP, allowing more airports to opt-in, and streamlining the contracting process.
The success of programs like NAV CANADA, which manages Canada’s air traffic control system after privatization in 1996, suggests that a well-managed partnership can deliver both efficiency and security.
FAQ: Private Security at Airports
- Are private security checkpoints as safe as TSA checkpoints? Yes, all security procedures are managed and supervised by the TSA, ensuring the same standards are met regardless of who performs the screening.
- Is private security more expensive? BOS Security claims private contractors can be more cost-effective, but the AFGE argues that prioritizing low bids can compromise safety.
- Can any airport switch to private security? No, airports must obtain permission from the TSA and go through a lengthy contracting process.
Pro Tip: Check FlightQueue or TSA Wait Times before heading to the airport to gain real-time updates on security line wait times.
What are your experiences with airport security? Share your thoughts in the comments below!
Related reading