The Evolution of the Two-Way Player: Beyond the Ohtani Phenomenon
For decades, professional baseball adhered to a strict divide: you were either a pitcher or a position player. While Shohei Ohtani has shattered that ceiling on a global scale, a recent trend is emerging within player development. Organizations are beginning to view “two-way” capability not as a rare anomaly, but as a strategic asset.
The Toronto Blue Jays are currently testing this frontier with prospect Austin Smith. A 10th-round pick in 2025, Smith is carving out a path as a “scrappy” outfielder who also serves as a relief pitcher for the Class A Dunedin Blue Jays. This shift represents a broader move toward flexibility in how talent is cultivated and utilized.
Maximizing the 26-Man Roster: A Strategic Shift
In the modern era of MLB, roster spots are the most valuable currency. With a strict 26-man limit, managers are constantly balancing the need for bullpen depth against the need for bench versatility. The emergence of the “hybrid” player offers a theoretical solution to this puzzle.
Blue Jays player development director Joe Sclafani compares the value of a two-way player to having an emergency catcher on the roster. By developing a player who can provide viable relief pitching in lower-leverage situations while remaining a productive outfielder, a team can effectively gain an extra roster spot.
This strategic flexibility allows a team to keep their primary bullpen arms rested while maintaining a competitive edge in the field. For Smith, In other words a specialized schedule—playing the outfield four or five times a week and dedicating Thursdays exclusively to pitching.
Breaking the Cookie-Cutter Mold in Player Development
The traditional “cookie-cutter” approach to player development—where every prospect follows a rigid, position-specific path—is being challenged. The trend is moving toward individualized plans that prioritize a player’s natural strengths over organizational tradition.
The Blue Jays’ approach with Smith signals a shift in how teams recruit. By demonstrating an openness to non-traditional roles, organizations can attract talented athletes who might otherwise feel limited by a single-position designation. This flexible environment encourages players to embrace their full athletic identity.
This development requires a high level of trust between the player and the manager. For example, Dunedin Blue Jays manager Ryan Casteel emphasizes an organic communication style to ensure the player is pushed without being “broken,” recognizing that the physical grind of two-way preparation is significantly more demanding than a standard role.
The Pipeline from College to the Pros
The trend of two-way professional players is being fueled by a growing pipeline of collegiate talent. Smith’s journey began at the University of San Diego, where he was a John Olerud Two-Way Player of the Year Award semifinalist. His college stats provided a blueprint for his professional potential:
- As a hitter: A .305 batting average with an .847 OPS.
- As a pitcher: 168 strikeouts across 161.2 innings.
As more college athletes prove they can maintain high-level performance in both disciplines, professional scouts—like those from the Blue Jays—are becoming more inclined to offer deals that preserve both skill sets rather than forcing a player to choose one.
For the aspiring two-way player, the goal is no longer just to be a novelty, but to be a “gamer.” This means possessing a diverse toolkit—power, contact, speed, and a fastball that can reach 92 m.p.h.—to impact the game in multiple ways.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a two-way player in baseball?
A two-way player is an athlete who regularly both pitches and plays a position in the field (such as the outfield) during the same season.
How does a two-way player help a team’s roster?
They provide versatility, allowing a team to maximize their limited roster spots by having one player fill two distinct roles, similar to how an emergency catcher provides backup security.
Who is Austin Smith?
Austin Smith is a Toronto Blue Jays prospect and a 10th-round pick in 2025 who is currently developing as a two-way outfielder and relief pitcher with the Dunedin Blue Jays.
What do you think about the rise of two-way players? Could this become a standard strategy for MLB teams to manage their 26-man rosters? Let us know in the comments below or subscribe to our newsletter for more deep dives into player development!
For more on current prospect trends, visit MLB.com or follow the latest updates on Sportsnet.