Whitemountain Quarries Limited has issued a formal apology to Geraldine Mullan at Letterkenny Circuit Criminal Court for safety failings that led to a 2020 road incident in Inishowen, Co Donegal, which claimed the lives of her husband and two children. John Mullan, 49, along with 14-year-old Tomás and six-year-old Amelia, died when their car plunged into Lough Foyle on August 20, 2020, as the family returned home to Moville after a day out in Derry.
Court Proceedings and Guilty Plea
During the court hearing, Whitemountain Quarries Limited pleaded guilty to breaches of the Safety, Health and Welfare at Work Act 2005 at the R238 Greenbank Project, Three Trees, Quigley’s Point. According to court evidence, the company acknowledged that it failed to manage and conduct the guiding of public traffic safely through roadworks. Declan Carr, CEO of the Breedon Group—which acquired Whitemountain Quarries in 2018—apologized unreservedly to Ms. Mullan on behalf of the company, stating that they failed to meet required safety standards on the night of the tragedy.
The prosecution detailed that Whitemountain Quarries had been carrying out resurfacing works on a 1.3km stretch of roadway for Donegal County Council starting on August 17, 2020. Ahead of schedule and facing an incoming national storm warning, a company engineer asked a subcontracted traffic management company to remove signage on August 20, 2020, intending to use their own cones. The stop-go system was lifted, and spot checks planned for the weekend did not occur that Thursday night. Testimony revealed the new road surface was at least 5cm higher than the hard shoulder, lacked central markings or visible cones on the northbound lane, and featured a very poor level of friction.
Details of the Incident and Rescue Efforts
At approximately 10.20pm on August 20, 2020, the Mullan family’s car was traveling northbound when the front passenger wheel slipped onto the hard shoulder within the roadworks zone. Forensic collision investigators confirmed the vehicle was roadworthy, not speeding, and did not contribute to the crash. As Mr. Mullan attempted to correct the steering, the car skidded across the road, slid over the embankment, and entered Lough Foyle. Ms. Mullan recalled hearing her family’s screams of terror before the vehicle overturned on the seabed.
Ms. Mullan managed to escape through a car window and secured herself on the vehicle’s axle against strong waves, continuing to scream for help as 20 to 25 cars drove past without stopping. Eventually, a passing family noticed her and raised the alarm. The bodies of John, Tomás, and Amelia Mullan were subsequently recovered from the water after dying by drowning. First responders formed a guard of honour as Ms. Mullan was brought in a wheelchair to make the sign of the cross on each of their heads and kiss them goodbye.
Impact and Victim Statement
Delivering her victim impact statement, Ms. Mullan described the immeasurable depth of her loss and her ongoing struggle with post-traumatic stress disorder, severe emotional trauma, and physical injuries. She detailed the vibrant lives of her husband John, her firstborn son Tomás—who planned to study pharmacy—and her daughter Amelia, who was bubbly and mischievous. She also highlighted the profound stress caused by repeated court adjournments over the period following the tragedy.
Legal representatives for the company noted its full cooperation with the Health and Safety Authority, its lack of previous convictions, and the implementation of new policies requiring director-level approval to stand down traffic management subcontractors. Judge Roderick Maguire directed the company to produce a document outlining specific steps taken to address identified shortcomings before finalizing sentencing next Friday. Whitemountain Quarries, which employs 170 people across Ireland and the UK, faces a maximum fine of €3 million.
Did You Know? Whitemountain Quarries Limited had been carrying out resurfacing works on a 1.3km stretch of roadway for Donegal County Council for just three days before the tragedy occurred on August 20, 2020.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who was involved in the incident in Inishowen?
The incident involved John Mullan (49), his children Tomás (14) and Amelia (6), and his wife Geraldine Mullan, who was the sole survivor of the car crash into Lough Foyle.
What charges did Whitemountain Quarries face in court?
Whitemountain Quarries Limited pleaded guilty to breaches of the Safety, Health and Welfare at Work Act 2005 concerning the failure to properly manage and conduct the guiding of public traffic through roadworks at the R238 Greenbank Project.
What is the maximum penalty the company faces?
The court heard that Whitemountain Quarries faces a maximum fine of €3 million, with sentencing scheduled to be finalized by Judge Roderick Maguire after the company submits documentation on new safety measures.
Related reading