<>
The Charity Commission for England and Wales has launched an official investigation into charities suspected of donating funds to illegal Israeli settlements in Palestine. The regulator intends to determine the total amount of charitable funds transferred to these settlements, assess whether such spending aligns with the charities’ stated purposes, and evaluate what regulatory action may be required.
The inquiry follows a series of reports and a formal complaint from Labour MP Melanie Ward, who alleged that 32 charities have donated at least £28m to settlements considered illegal under international law. While the commission is initially focusing on eight unnamed charities, it has indicated that it plans to expand the scope of its investigation over time.
Regulatory Oversight and Financial Compliance
Stephen Roake, the assistant director for high-risk compliance at the Charity Commission, stated that the agency’s first priority is to establish the facts regarding these allegations. “Only then can we determine if regulatory action is required, based on our findings and the evidence we see,” Roake said. The commission noted that it has already shared information regarding the scope of its inquiry with the police and HMRC.
The investigation is expected to examine the locations of the charities’ partners and the timing of the alleged financial activities. The regulator has not yet named the eight charities currently under review but stated it would consider doing so upon the publication of its findings. Meanwhile, the Metropolitan Police’s war crimes unit confirmed it is not currently investigating any charities in relation to these donations.
Did You Know?
Last year, reporting revealed that two UK charities had transferred approximately £5.7m to the Bnei Akiva Yeshiva high school in Susya, located in Israeli-occupied territory. More recently, it was disclosed that the charity Friends of Yeshivat Shavei Hevron sent nearly £200,000 to a religious school in Hebron between 2019 and 2024.
Political Pressure and Potential Outcomes
The investigation arrives after sustained pressure from parliamentarians. In June, then-foreign secretary Yvette Cooper informed MPs that she had asked the regulator to examine the issue, citing concerns that charity systems were being “abused to funnel support to illegal settlements” and that UK gift aid tax relief was being utilized for this purpose.
Some lawmakers have pushed for more aggressive measures. Melanie Ward and 140 Labour colleagues have advocated for a total ban on such donations, with Ward noting that the commission appeared to have been aware of the issue since July of last year. Abtisam Mohamed, a Labour MP and member of the foreign affairs committee, stated that the commission must investigate all 32 identified charities, characterizing the funding of illegal settlements as “extremist activity” that bears no relation to legitimate charitable work.
Expert Insight:
The significance of this inquiry lies in the intersection of international law and domestic charitable status.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the primary goal of the Charity Commission’s investigation?
The commission aims to establish the total amount of charitable funds transferred to illegal settlements, verify if the spending aligns with the charities’ purposes, and decide if regulatory action is necessary.
How many charities are currently under investigation?
The investigation is initially focusing on eight unnamed charities, though the commission has stated it plans to extend the inquiry to additional organizations over time.
Are there any criminal investigations currently underway regarding these donations?
No. While the Charity Commission has shared information with the police and HMRC, the Metropolitan Police’s war crimes unit has stated it is not currently investigating any charities in relation to these donations.
How will the findings of this inquiry influence future guidelines for charitable organizations operating in conflict zones?
Related reading