St Basil’s Inquest: Management Accountability and Oversight Failures
The St Basil’s aged care facility tragedy, which saw nearly a quarter of 188 residents die during a 2020 Covid-19 outbreak, remains the subject of a coronial inquest examining management failures. Senior managers Konstantin Kontis and Vicky Kos were compelled to testify following multiple failed legal bids to avoid providing evidence. The inquest, which coincides with the sixth anniversary of the crisis, is scrutinizing the lack of board oversight, missing documentation, and the failure of management to follow government pandemic directives.
Board Oversight and Delegated Authority
Konstantin Kontis, who served as chair of the St Basil’s board, admitted under questioning that he did not have the authority to approve the facility’s Covid-19 management policy without board approval. Counsel assisting the coroner, Naomi Hodgson, highlighted that the policy lacked robust guidance for managing close contacts and failed to update in alignment with shifting government directives.
Instead of formal policy updates, staff were directed to a “yellow folder” containing printed government information. Kontis acknowledged that there was no delegation of authority allowing him to bypass the board for such a critical document. Furthermore, the court heard that no minutes were found from an April 2020 board meeting—a period when the facility should have been preparing for potential workforce infections. This discovery forced a delay in the inquest to allow for a broader search of approximately 10,000 pages of evidence.
Missing Records and Operational Control
A central issue raised during the inquest is the absence of a documented cohort plan to separate Covid-positive residents from those who remained uninfected. Vicky Kos, the former director of nursing and facility manager, testified that the plan was held in the aforementioned yellow folder. However, a search of electronic and physical files, including those previously seized by Victoria Police, failed to locate the document.
St Basil’s barrister, Conor O’Bryan, stated that because files were lost, it could not be proven that a cohort plan never existed. The lack of transparency extended to the transition of care, as agency staff brought in to manage the facility reported struggling to access basic information, including computer passwords and clinical notes. Kontis maintained that such information was available in various folders throughout the kitchen and maintenance areas.
Management Absence During Critical Meetings
Evidence presented to the court revealed that Kontis did not attend key meetings with health officials as the outbreak escalated. When questioned by Hodgson regarding his absence, Kontis stated he disagreed with a directive from the then-chief health officer, Prof. Brett Sutton, to furlough the entire workforce.
“I can’t answer that. I didn’t attend,” Kontis responded when asked why he was not present at meetings where the decision to replace the workforce was discussed. He further claimed he could not convene the risk and audit committee because he “couldn’t get anybody to attend a meeting because of Covid,” a claim Hodgson dismissed as improbable given the availability of remote communication.
Compliance and Communication Barriers
Kos testified that 95% of the original staff at St Basil’s spoke English as a second language and lacked access to computers. Consequently, critical Covid-19 updates were communicated via simple signs and verbal handovers. Regarding the initial outbreak on 9 July 2020, Kos admitted she failed to email the commonwealth department of health within the required 30-minute window, a step that could have triggered immediate assistance with testing and PPE.
Both Kontis and Kos were granted a certificate by coroner Liberty Sanger, ensuring their evidence cannot be used against them in future criminal or civil litigation. For families of the deceased, such as Spiros Vasilakis, the testimony has been painful. “I can tell you that families remember, detail by detail, what occurred,” Vasilakis said.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why was the St Basil’s inquest delayed?
The inquest was delayed to allow representatives for St Basil’s to search for missing board meeting minutes, which were not found among the 10,000 pages of evidence provided to the coroner.
What was the “yellow folder” mentioned in court?
The yellow folder served as the primary repository for Covid-19 management information at the facility. Management expected staff to check it regularly for updates, though counsel suggested this was an inadequate system for high-stakes infection control.
Are the witnesses protected from legal repercussions?
Yes. Coroner Liberty Sanger granted a certificate to Konstantin Kontis and Vicky Kos, which prevents their testimony at the inquest from being used against them in future civil or criminal proceedings.
Are you following the developments in the aged care sector? Subscribe to our newsletter for ongoing updates on this inquest and other industry news.
Related reading