According to tournament records, the EFL Cup—widely known as the Carabao Cup—has produced some of the most chaotic scorelines and dramatic finishes in English football history, ranging from 12-goal thrillers to penalty shootouts lasting nearly as long as a regulation match. While major clubs frequently use early rounds to integrate youth prospects and shed pre-season rust, these fixtures often erupt into staggering, high-scoring affairs.
Dagenham & Redbridge 6–6 Brentford (2-4 pens): A 2014 Goal Fest
According to match archives, the August 13, 2014 first-round tie at Victoria Road stands as the joint-highest scoring EFL Cup match in history. Pitting League Two side Dagenham & Redbridge against a newly promoted Championship Brentford squad, the fixture finished 4-4 after 90 minutes before descending into a wild extra-time shootout.
The Daggers surged ahead 6-5 in the 113th minute, only for Brentford’s Harlee Dean to equalize in the 117th minute. In the subsequent penalty shootout, misses from Jack Connors and Ashley Chambers doomed Dagenham, allowing Brentford skipper Kevin O’Connor to convert the winning spot-kick, as reported by competition historians.
Reading 5–7 Arsenal: The 2012 Madejski Stadium Comeback
According to official match reports from October 30, 2012, Arsenal engineered one of the competition’s most astonishing comebacks during a fourth-round encounter at the Madejski Stadium. Playing in the Premier League without a win at the time, Reading stunned the Gunners by racing to a 4-0 lead within 35 minutes.
Theo Walcott’s strike before halftime sparked an Arsenal revival that forced extra time at 5-5. Marouane Chamakh and Walcott eventually secured a 7-5 victory for Arsenal, punctuated by the farcical sight of Olivier Giroud and Francis Coquelin prematurely throwing their shirts into the crowd before realizing extra time remained.
Did you know?
The Carabao Cup has twice witnessed 12-goal thrillers in its history: Dagenham & Redbridge vs. Brentford in 2014 and Reading vs. Arsenal in 2012. Both fixtures required extra time to separate the sides.
Preston North End 1–1 Fulham (16-15 pens): The Record Shootout
According to tournament data, the September 17, 2024 third-round clash between Preston North End and Fulham at Deepdale set the record for the longest penalty shootout in League Cup history. After a 1-1 draw in regulation—featuring an opener by Preston midfielder Ryan Ledson—the teams labored through a staggering 34 spot-kicks.
With 31 penalties successfully converted, the marathon finally ended when Fulham’s Timothy Castagne missed over the crossbar, allowing Ledson to dispatch the decisive penalty and send Paul Heckingbottom’s side into the fourth round. The fixture eclipsed the previous record set in 2016, when Derby County defeated Carlisle United 14-13 on penalties.
West Ham United 10–0 Bury: The 1983 Milk Cup Rout
According to historical records from October 25, 1983, West Ham United recorded their largest-ever win in domestic competition during a two-legged Milk Cup second-round tie at the Boleyn Ground. Holding a narrow 2-1 aggregate lead from the first leg against Fourth Division Bury, John Lyall’s Division One leaders blew the tie wide open.
Tony Cottee netted four goals—completing a first-half hat-trick alongside efforts from Alvin Martin and Trevor Brooking—as the Hammers established a 5-0 halftime lead. Further strikes from Alan Devonshire, Ray Stewart, and Brooking completed a double-digit demolition.
Manchester City 10–0 Burton Albion: The 2019 Semi-Final Masterclass
According to semi-final accounts from January 9, 2019, Manchester City dismantled League One outfit Burton Albion 10-0 on aggregate. Gabriel Jesus scored four goals in the first leg at the Etihad Stadium, supported by strikes from Kevin de Bruyne, Oleksandr Zinchenko, Phil Foden, Kyle Walker, and Riyad Mahrez.
Burton manager Nigel Clough noted after the match that City manager Pep Guardiola invited him in for a glass of wine, joking that he hoped the Spaniard poured more than one. City completed the victory with a 1-0 win in the second leg at the Pirelli Stadium.
Liverpool 10–0 Fulham: The 1986 Anfield Demolition
According to September 23, 1986 records, league champions Liverpool overwhelmed Third Division Fulham 10-0 in the first leg of their second-round tie at Anfield. Steve McMahon scored four goals and missed a penalty, while Ian Rush and John Wark each struck twice. Ronnie Whelan and Steve Nicol rounded out the scoring in a match that culminated in a 13-2 aggregate victory for the Reds.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the highest-scoring match in Carabao Cup history?
According to tournament records, the joint-highest scoring matches are Dagenham & Redbridge 6–6 Brentford (2014) and Reading 5–7 Arsenal (2012), both featuring 12 goals.
What is the longest penalty shootout in League Cup history?
According to EFL records, Preston North End’s 16-15 win over Fulham in September 2024 stands as the longest shootout, requiring 34 penalties.
Who holds the record for the largest aggregate win in a semi-final?
Manchester City defeated Burton Albion 10-0 on aggregate during the 2019 semi-finals.
Join the Conversation: What is the wildest Carabao Cup match you have ever witnessed in person or on television? Drop a comment below, share this article with fellow football fans, and subscribe to our newsletter for more historical analysis and tournament updates.