U.S. District Judge Richard Leon ruled on Friday that the Trump administration may proceed with building 62 miles of border wall along the Tohono O’odham Nation’s reservation in Arizona. The judge denied the tribe’s request to halt construction, finding that government interests in border security outweigh potential harms.
The ruling clears the way for the Department of Homeland Security to move forward with barrier construction without the consent of the Tohono O’odham Nation. Judge Leon, who was nominated to the bench by former Republican President George W. Bush, determined that the tribe failed to prove the wall would change its reservation boundaries without the authority of Congress.
The Legal Dispute Over Tribal Trespass
At the center of the case is whether the federal government exceeded its legal powers by bypassing tribal approval. Senior Judge Richard Leon of the US District Court for the District of Columbia found that the Tohono O’odham Nation isn’t likely to win on its claim that the Department of Homeland Security exceeded its legal powers by moving forward with barrier construction without the tribe’s approval. He characterized this type of claim as the ultimate ‘Hail Mary pass’ and noted that the Nation was unlikely to clear this high bar.
The judge also dismissed the claim that the wall would constitute an illegal trespass on the reservation. In his decision, Leon balanced the competing interests of the sovereign tribe and the federal government.
“And in any event, I find that the Government’s interests in securing the border, enforcing immigration laws, and ensuring public safety outweigh any surviving irreparable harms at this juncture.”
Judge Richard Leon, via AP News
Tohono O’odham Nation: Sacred Sites and Family Ties
The Tohono O’odham reservation spans 2.8 million acres in Arizona’s Sonoran Desert, with 62 miles of its land abutting the U.S.-Mexico border. The tribe consists of more than 37,000 members, including thousands who reside in Mexico. Tribal attorneys argued that the wall would cause significant devastation,
specifically citing the destruction of mountain peaks that are sacred to the O’odham.
Beyond the physical landscape, the tribe warned that the barrier would sever critical social and spiritual connections. Attorneys wrote that the project would fray the ties between O’odham communities and families on opposite sides of the border, interfere significantly with O’odham religious rituals and practices, and destroy plant and animal resources sacred to the O’odham.
“Too many critical issues were not adequately addressed, such as inevitable impacts construction will have on the Nation’s land and the permanent destruction of sacred sites. The Nation will consider all possible options for moving forward, as this issue is simply too important to the O’odham.”
Verlon M. Jose, Tohono O’odham Nation Chairman, via AP News
The 1907 Roosevelt Reservation Conflict
A primary point of contention involves the Roosevelt Reservation, a 60-foot strip of public land along the border established by President Theodore Roosevelt in 1907. This buffer zone was created a decade before the Tohono O’odham reservation was formally established.
The government’s position relies on this strip of land, but tribal lawyers argued that the idea of confining a massive border wall to a narrow 60-foot corridor is fanciful at best.
Judicial Skepticism and Novelty
During a hearing on July 22, Judge Leon expressed skepticism regarding the tribe’s request for a preliminary injunction, which he labeled as an “extraordinary” request. He noted that the case presented novel issues and stated he could not find any previous court ruling under comparable circumstances.
This is a novel case with novel issues,
the judge said.
The ruling ensures the administration can continue taking the necessary steps to build the wall. Chairman Verlon M.
Related reading