Ukrainian intelligence officials report that Russia is organizing military battalions composed of Ukrainian prisoners of war (POWs). According to the Security Service of Ukraine (SBU), these units are being documented and monitored, raising concerns over potential violations of the Geneva Conventions, which prohibit the forced service of prisoners in the forces of an adversary.
SBU and International Observations of POW Battalions
The Security Service of Ukraine (SBU) has confirmed the existence of these specialized military units. Andrii Pasternak, who leads the SBU department responsible for matters involving prisoners of war and illegally detained persons, stated that Ukrainian intelligence is actively documenting these cases in coordination with military and foreign intelligence services.
These reports align with assessments from the Institute for the Study of War (ISW). The think tank previously noted the formation of a specialized brigade consisting of Ukrainian captives and alleged deserters within the Russian military structure. While Russian state-controlled media outlets, such as RIA Novosti, have claimed these soldiers joined "voluntarily" and pledged allegiance to Moscow, international observers remain skeptical. Yulia Gorbunova of Human Rights Watch noted that it is difficult to imagine a scenario where a prisoner of war can make a decision that is truly voluntary given the power imbalance inherent in captivity.
Legal Implications and the Geneva Conventions
The forced recruitment of prisoners of war into an enemy’s armed forces constitutes a serious violation of international humanitarian law. Under the Geneva Conventions, forcing a captive to perform military duties is strictly prohibited.
Cecilie Hellestveit, an expert in the law of war, emphasizes the severity of these allegations. While noting that Russia has generally exercised caution regarding the forced conscription of Ukrainian civilians for regular military tasks, she characterizes the reported integration of POWs as a significant departure from previous patterns. According to Hellestveit, such an escalation would represent a marked breach of established policy, potentially creating long-term diplomatic and legal repercussions for Russia.
Historical Context of Reported POW Recruitment
The use of Ukrainian captives by Russian forces has been a subject of international concern since the early stages of the full-scale invasion. The Institute for the Study of War first highlighted reports of Russian interest in utilizing Ukrainian POWs as early as November 2022.
By October 2023, reports in outlets like Business Insider indicated that Russian authorities were planning to deploy a battalion of approximately 70 Ukrainian prisoners to the front lines. At that time, Russian state media claimed these individuals possessed prior combat experience. While these claims of "voluntary" service have persisted in Russian media narratives, they remain unverified by independent international observers.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is it legal for Russia to use Ukrainian POWs as soldiers?
No. According to the Geneva Conventions, forcing prisoners of war to serve in the armed forces of a detaining power is considered a serious violation of international law.
Are these soldiers joining voluntarily?
Russian state media claims that prisoners are joining voluntarily and swearing allegiance to Russia. However, experts like Yulia Gorbunova of Human Rights Watch argue that the inherent power imbalance in captivity makes true voluntary consent impossible to establish.
How long has this been occurring?
Reports regarding the potential use of Ukrainian prisoners in Russian military units have circulated since late 2022, shortly after the start of the full-scale conflict.
Did you know?
The Geneva Conventions address forced service as a serious breach, aimed at preventing the exploitation of prisoners of war.
Stay informed on the latest developments in international security and the conflict in Ukraine. Subscribe to our newsletter or explore our archives for ongoing coverage of humanitarian issues in the region.
Related reading