According to Associated Press reporting, the Pittsburgh Steelers navigated a stark preseason performance swing following a 28-9 victory against the Green Bay Packers on August 13 with a subsequent 17-0 shutout loss to the New York Jets on Friday. Quarterbacks Will Howard and Drew Allar posted a combined 142.1 passer rating in the opener before dropping to an aggregate 46.4 rating against the Jets, highlighting the volatility of early-game evaluations for the squad.
Mason Rudolph Secures Backup Role Amid Preseason Volatility
According to the primary source material, veteran quarterback Mason Rudolph solidified his spot on the season-opening active roster simply by not playing in the team’s shutout defeat. With nine years of NFL experience and an 8-5-1 career record for the franchise, Rudolph provides a stable security blanket behind 42-year-old starter Aaron Rodgers. While young signal-callers Will Howard and Allar struggled to put points on the board against New York, the coaching staff’s reliance on Rudolph’s veteran presence remains secure.
Reporting further highlights that Rudolph returned to Pittsburgh on a two-year deal in March after a one-season stint in Tennessee, knowing he would not be the immediate starter. Despite missing out on starting duties, Rudolph took all the reps with the first team while Aaron Rodgers weighed returning for his 21st NFL season. Head coach Mike Tomlin praised Rudolph’s reliability after he completed 12 of 16 passes for 127 yards and a touchdown during a later regular-season contest against the Cincinnati Bengals, noting that the veteran consistently delivers when called upon.
Defensive Impact From Returning Veterans
According to team reports, safeties and linebackers returning from injury or new to the roster made immediate impacts against the Jets. Safety DeShon Elliott started and played a quarter, recording a forced fumble and four overall tackles after recovering from knee surgery last fall. Linebacker Elandon Roberts, signed on August 13 after playing for the Las Vegas Raiders last season, entered the game in the third quarter and racked up five total tackles, making stops on his very first defensive snap and on a Jets fourth-down attempt.
Beyond individual performances, the second-team defense settled in after allowing an opening-drive touchdown to Jets starter Geno Smith. During the subsequent nine drives, the unit surrendered just five first downs and 143 total yards. Standouts like Cam Heyward, T.J. Watt, Jalen Ramsey, Joey Porter Jr., Jaquan Brisker, and Brandin Echols sat out the contest, allowing younger depth pieces valuable reps.
Offensive Line Struggles and Special Teams Concerns
According to game analysis, the offensive line faced heavy pressure for the second week. The Jets recorded four sacks and five quarterback hits, while the Steelers managed an average of just 3.8 yards per rushing attempt with no carries exceeding 8 yards. Tackles Broderick Jones and Dylan Cook struggled heavily against Jets edge rushers and defensive tackles.

In the special teams unit, rookie return specialist Kaden Wetjen suffered a first-quarter fumble against New York. Despite improving his raw numbers slightly with a 15-yard punt return, the lack of secure ball handling threatens to cost him the trust of the coaching staff. Undrafted rookie kicker Laith Marjan also missed his lone opportunity, sending a 44-yard field goal attempt wide left in the third quarter.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who are the backup quarterbacks behind Aaron Rodgers for the Steelers?
According to team reports, veteran Mason Rudolph serves as the primary backup to Aaron Rodgers, with rookies Will Howard and Drew Allar competing for development reps.
How did Elandon Roberts and DeShon Elliott perform in their return?
According to game stats, DeShon Elliott recorded four tackles and a forced fumble in one quarter of play, while Elandon Roberts added five total tackles after entering the game in the third quarter.
What were the main issues for the Steelers offense against the Jets?
According to team analysis, the offensive line allowed four sacks and five quarterback hits while the rushing attack failed to record a single carry of 8 yards or more.
Pro Tip: Keep an eye on roster cuts and depth chart shifts as coaching staffs balance veteran security with the upside of young draft picks during the final weeks of the preseason.
Want to stay updated on all the latest roster moves and training camp analysis? Drop a comment below, explore our other team breakdowns, and subscribe to our newsletter for real-time updates.
Related reading