Gift card tampering scams involving major retailers like Coles have resulted in criminal convictions, according to court documents, as police urge shoppers to inspect packaging carefully for scratches, missing redemption codes, or altered seals before purchase. NSW Police and Coles monitored a man accused of tampering with cards at Sydney supermarkets, leading to his arrest and conviction after he allegedly handled 61 cards worth more than $10,000.
Did you know? Apple’s newer packaging includes perforated edges designed to show obvious signs of tampering. Investigators advise never buying a gift card if the package appears even slightly damaged or altered.
How Gift Card Tampering Schemes Operate
Perpetrators target physical gift cards displayed on open retail racks, compromising them before returning them to the shelves for unsuspecting customers to buy. According to court documents from a July 2025 case, scammers carefully scratch off protective coatings to reveal redemption codes or replace packaging entirely.
Shoppers who opened their newly purchased cards have found missing redemption numbers, scratched-off PINs, or balances completely drained by fraudsters. In some documented instances, victims discovered the card had already been fully redeemed before they even opened the present. Reported losses from these manipulated cards range from hundreds to thousands of dollars per incident.
Pro Tip: Whenever possible, select gift cards stored securely behind a service counter rather than grabbing them from open display stands. Always retain your original purchase receipt, card packaging, and activation details.
Police Investigation and Conviction Details
Law enforcement agencies and major corporate security teams are actively cracking down on retail gift card fraud. Court documents show that Coles security personnel and NSW Police collaborated to track a suspect tampering with cards across multiple Sydney supermarkets.
During a coordinated search of the man’s home and car in May 2025, authorities uncovered dozens of Apple and iTunes cards. This evidence culminated in a July 2025 court conviction after the accused was found to have handled 61 compromised cards with a collective value exceeding $10,000.
Actionable Steps to Protect Your Purchases
Avoiding fraudulent gift cards requires careful physical inspection before handing over any money at the checkout register. Buyers should scrutinize packaging for tears, bent edges, unusual glue residue, clean cuts, or visible scratches where a security seal has been lifted and reapplied.
- Inspect Packaging Closely: Reject any card showing the slightest sign of tampering or structural damage.
- Encourage Prompt Redemption: If giving a gift card as a present, advise the recipient to open and redeem the balance immediately.
- Consider Digital Alternatives: Buying digital gift cards directly through an official brand website largely eliminates the risks associated with physical store tampering.
- Act Quickly on Fraud: If a card has a zero balance or missing details, contact the retailer and card issuer immediately with photos, packaging, and receipts. Report suspected fraud to Scamwatch, your bank, and local police.
National Seniors Australia Guidance: National Seniors Australia provides Keep Scam SAFE resources covering shopping, phishing, investment, and impersonation scams. Their guidance highlights a simple rule: Stop, Check, and Reject any transaction or request that feels suspicious.
Frequently Asked Questions
What should I do if my new gift card has a zero balance?
Contact the retailer and the card issuer immediately. Provide your purchase receipt, activation information, photographs of the card, and any remaining packaging to support your claim.
Are digital gift cards safer than physical ones?
Digital gift cards purchased directly through official company websites reduce the physical tampering risks that affect cards displayed on open retail racks.
How can I spot a tampered physical gift card?
Look closely for bent edges, tears, cut packaging, unusual glue, scratches, or lifted seals. Apple’s newer packaging features perforated edges that should clearly display signs if they have been previously opened.
Who should I contact if I lose money to a gift card scam?
Report suspected fraud to Scamwatch. If money has been stolen, contact your financial institution and local police right away to limit potential damage.
Related reading