According to the National Park Service, the Statue of Liberty’s torch balcony has remained closed to the public since July 30, 1916, when an act of wartime sabotage on a nearby munitions depot sent shrapnel tearing through the monument’s arm and damaged its internal framework. While visitors can still climb into the crown, the 40-foot ladder leading to the iconic torch has stayed sealed for 110 years.
The Black Tom Explosion of July 1916
The closure stems from a massive explosion at Black Tom, a mile-long rail terminal and munitions depot in Jersey City that jutted into New York Harbor directly behind the Statue of Liberty. According to FBI historical accounts, neutral America was actively selling roughly two million pounds of ammunition and explosives to Britain and France at the time. Imperial Germany operated a sabotage network inside the United States to disrupt those shipments. Small fires set by German agents triggered a blast at 2:08 a.m. on July 30, 1916.
According to historical estimates, the blast matched the force of a magnitude-5 earthquake, shattering windows across lower Manhattan and Jersey City. Shrapnel rained over the harbor, forcing the evacuation of detained immigrants on Ellis Island. The National Park Service notes that the shock wave pushed the statue’s torch arm against the crown and damaged the statue’s internal framework. Although the confirmed death toll was small due to the early hour, the physical toll on the monument permanently altered tourist access.
Did you know?
The clock on the Jersey Journal building stopped at 2:12 a.m. on the night of the blast, preserving the exact moment of the explosion for decades.
Structural Vulnerabilities and the Copper Flame Replacement
Gustave Eiffel’s engineering team had already built the statue’s internal iron framework and copper skin with a slight structural misalignment in the arm back in 1886. The Black Tom shrapnel exacerbated these hidden vulnerabilities. According to National Park Service records, the torch ladder was closed immediately that year and missed subsequent reopenings, including the 1938 refurbishment, the 1980s centennial restoration, and post-9/11 upgrades.
The battered original flame, which sculptor Gutzon Borglum repaired with glass panes in 1916, was eventually removed during the 1984–86 restoration project because it leaked rainwater. Workers replaced it with a modern copper flame gilded in gold leaf. Visitors can view the original 1886 flame at ground level inside the Statue of Liberty Museum, while National Park Service maintenance staff are the only people permitted to use the ladder to service floodlights on the current torch balcony.
Legal Fallout and the Path to Reparations
Proving state-directed sabotage required decades of investigation through the German-American Mixed Claims Commission. According to federal archives, the process faced extensive diplomatic denials, forged evidence, and delays caused by the outbreak of the Second World War. Germany was formally found responsible in 1939, leading to a $50 million settlement agreement in 1953. Final financial installments were completed in 1979—sixty-three years after the initial sabotage.
Today, Black Tom is largely absorbed into Liberty State Park as landfill, marked by a modest plaque and a circle of flags. The Statue of Liberty itself remains the most visible surviving monument to the attack, bearing the scars of an unpublicized war fought on American soil before the nation officially entered the conflict.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can visitors still access the Statue of Liberty crown?
Yes. While the torch balcony remains closed, a pre-booked fraction of daily visitors can still climb the 162 steps into the statue’s crown.
Why was the torch never reopened after repairs?
According to the National Park Service, the explosion damaged the statue’s internal framework and worsened existing misalignments in the raised arm, prompting safety officials to permanently restrict public access to the narrow 40-foot ladder.
Where is the original torch located today?
The original 1886 torch was removed during the 1984–86 restoration and is now housed at the Statue of Liberty Museum on Liberty Island.
Explore More Historical Insights
Have thoughts on this piece of hidden history? Leave a comment below or subscribe to our newsletter for more deep dives into archival stories.