Administrative Court Ruling Reinstates Investigator Čurilla, Annuls Minister’s Orders

On Thursday, November 19, police investigator Ján Čurilla returns to work at the Bratislava I District Directorate of the Police Corps after the Bratislava Municipal Court’s ruling to annul his suspension became legally binding.

Court Rulings on Čurilla and Suspension

The legal battle surrounding the investigator’s suspension stems from a 2023 personnel order issued by Minister of the Interior Matúš Šutaj Eštok. Čurilla and his colleagues faced charges brought by the inspection service in September 2021, an accusation that the minister used to place the officers out of service.

Bratislavské súdy later refused to accept the indictment in the case. The inspection service had expanded the original investigation to include Milan Sabota, Štefan Mašin, and the then-acting inspection director Peter Scholtz, according to Denník N.

The Bratislava Municipal Court officially annulled the minister’s February 23, 2024 decision and the October 27, 2023 personnel order, according to court documents cited by Pravda. Minister of the Interior Matúš Šutaj Eštok has continued to publicly criticize the group, claiming in recent statements that the investigators turned their work into a “hunt.”

Implications for the Ministry of the Interior

The Ministry of the Interior faces multiple legal defeats regarding its personnel actions against police officers. The ministry previously lost three separate administrative disputes involving Čurilla’s team members, including Pavol Ďurka, Juraj Svítok, and Branko Kišš, as reported by Aktuality.sk.

The Administrative Court in Banská Bystrica ruled in September in favor of inspection official Juraj Svítok, annulling a personnel order that had demoted him to the Bánovce nad Bebravou District Directorate.

Administrative Court Ruling Reinstates Investigator Čurilla, Annuls Minister's Orders
Photo: Aktuality

While the ministry may file a cassation complaint with the Supreme Administrative Court, legal representatives said that such a filing carries no suspensive effect. Attorney Martina Filipová said that the ministry’s legal counsel would evaluate the written justification before determining further procedural steps.

Regarding Čurilla’s specific case, Filipová noted: “Rešpektujem rozhodnutie Správneho súdu v Bratislave, ktorým súd zrušil rozhodnutia ministerstva o dočasnom pozbavení Jána Čurillu výkonu štátnej služby pre absenciu predchádzajúceho súhlasu Úradu na ochranu oznamovateľov.”, according to Aktuality

Expert Insight: Repeated annulments of ministerial personnel orders by municipal and administrative courts highlight strict judicial oversight regarding statutory prerequisites for sidelining active-duty law enforcement personnel. Although higher courts offer avenues for appeal, the immediate reinstatement orders underscore the practical challenges administrative authorities face when procedural prerequisites like anti-retaliation protections are bypassed.

Investigator resumes duties at original district directorate tomorrow

Following the dissolution of the National Criminal Agency (NAKA) and the omission of Čurilla from the Anti-Organized Crime Office, the returning investigator will report to his initial assignment at the Bratislava I District Directorate. Legal representatives and observers indicate that further employment disputes remain possible given the contentious history between the police officers and the current ministerial leadership.

“Na základe nedávneho rozsudku Správneho súdu v Bratislave, ktorý dnes nadobudol právoplatnosť, sa od zajtrajšieho rána vracia do práce nezákonne odstavený vyšetrovateľ PZ plk. Ján Čurilla,” said Peter Kubina, attorney for Ján Čurilla.

Administrative Court Ruling Reinstates Investigator Čurilla, Annuls Minister's Orders
Photo: Pravda

Court ruling reinstates investigator to Bratislava district directorate

Why was Ján Čurilla originally suspended from duty?

Minister of the Interior Matúš Šutaj Eštok placed Čurilla and other investigators out of service in the autumn of 2023 following criminal charges related to the abuse of official powers.

Where will Ján Čurilla report upon his return to work?

Because the National Criminal Agency was dissolved and he was not assigned to the Anti-Organized Crime Office, Čurilla returns to the Bratislava I District Directorate of the Police Corps, where his career began.

What did the administrative court decide regarding the legal costs?

The Bratislava Municipal Court ordered the Ministry of the Interior to pay the full procedural costs of the lawsuit to the plaintiff while denying reimbursement claims made by the General Prosecutor’s Office.