America’s Next Top Model: The Toxic Truth

The Reality Check: How ‘America’s Next Top Model’ Sparked a Reckoning in Reality TV

A new three-part docuseries, Reality Check: Inside America’s Next Top Model, now streaming on Netflix, is forcing a re-evaluation of the long-running competition show and its impact. The series isn’t shying away from the problematic aspects of the program, particularly the role of host Tyra Banks, and is prompting viewers to question the ethics of early 2000s reality television.

From Inspiration to Investigation

America’s Next Top Model (ANTM), which aired from 2003 to 2018, presented itself as a platform for aspiring models. The show offered a contract, a cash prize, and a magazine photoshoot to the winner. However, the Netflix docuseries reveals a far more troubling reality, suggesting the show was far more damaging than inspirational.

The Extreme Makeover: A Look Back at Controversial Challenges

A signature element of ANTM was the “makeover” segment. Initially, these involved minor changes like new hairstyles or eyebrow shaping. But as the series progressed, the makeovers became increasingly drastic. One particularly shocking example highlighted in the docuseries involves a contestant in season 15 undergoing a dental procedure to create a gap between her teeth, deemed more “high fashion.”

These practices, viewed through a 2026 lens, are now widely considered boundary-pushing. Contestants faced immense pressure and had limited agency, driven by the hope of a successful career.

Bodyshaming and the Pressure to Conform

The docuseries also tackles the issue of bodyshaming, which was normalized throughout the show’s run. While criticism of body image in the modeling world isn’t new, the visual and public nature of it on ANTM is presented as particularly harmful to young viewers.

Tyra Banks, who positioned herself as a role model, is shown to have contributed to a toxic environment that demanded adherence to extreme beauty standards. Banks herself acknowledges going “too far,” but also attributes the show’s escalation to audience demand.

Drama as a Driver: The Pursuit of Ratings

The series suggests that shocking storylines were intentionally produced to boost ratings. The docuseries questions where the line should be drawn when it comes to entertainment, and whether the pursuit of viewership justifies potential long-term psychological harm to participants.

Voices from the Past: Jury Members Speak Out

Former judges, including photographer Nigel Barker, Miss J, and stylist Jay Manuel, also share their perspectives. Their accounts reveal a climate of mistrust, betrayal, and a relentless focus on success. Manuel alleges that Banks prioritized the show’s success above all else.

ANTM in 2026: A Show That Couldn’t Exist Today

What was once considered innovative television would likely be cancelled in 2026. The docuseries encourages critical examination of reality TV and the need for progress within the industry. It prompts viewers to question what is presented to them on screen.

The Broader Implications for Reality Television

The controversy surrounding America’s Next Top Model isn’t isolated. It reflects a growing scrutiny of the reality TV genre as a whole. Shows are increasingly being held accountable for the psychological impact on participants and the ethical implications of manufactured drama.

The Rise of Ethical Reality TV

Viewers are demanding more responsible production practices. This includes providing comprehensive mental health support for contestants, ensuring fair and transparent judging criteria, and avoiding exploitative challenges. Several newer reality shows are prioritizing contestant well-being, featuring therapists on set and implementing stricter guidelines for producers.

The Power of Docuseries in Holding Shows Accountable

The success of docuseries like Reality Check demonstrates the public’s appetite for critical analysis of popular culture. These series provide a platform for former participants and industry insiders to share their experiences, exposing the darker side of reality television. This increased transparency can lead to positive change within the industry.

The Future of Competition Shows

Competition shows are likely to evolve, focusing less on sensationalism and more on genuine skill development and personal growth. Expect to see more emphasis on mentorship, positive reinforcement, and celebrating individuality. The focus may shift from finding a single “winner” to showcasing the journeys of all participants.

Frequently Asked Questions

• What is Reality Check: Inside America’s Next Top Model about? It’s a docuseries on Netflix that examines the problematic aspects of the reality show America’s Next Top Model.
• What is Tyra Banks’ role in the controversy? The docuseries scrutinizes Banks’ role as host and creator of the show, highlighting her contribution to a potentially harmful environment.
• Has America’s Next Top Model been cancelled? The show originally ended in 2018, but the docuseries has sparked renewed discussion about why it wouldn’t be viable today.

You can stream Reality Check: Inside America’s Next Top Model on Netflix now. For a lighter watch, consider the New Wave documentary on Videoland.

What are your thoughts on the show? Share your opinions in the comments below!