Somehow, some way, 59-year-old Andrew Shue and 49-year-old Marilee Fiebig have a happy ending, sharing their first wedding photo weeks after their exes tied the knot.
The newlyweds stand close together and smile for the camera against a picturesque backdrop of trees and countryside buildings, according to a joint Instagram post shared on Sunday. Shue wore a dark suit and tie while Fiebig wore a white lace gown with an updo, holding a bouquet, as reported by TMZ.
“Somehow, some way, this story has a happy ending and now a beautiful new beginning,” the pair captioned the photo.
The couple married at their 92-acre country estate near Stockton, New Jersey, with only close friends and family in attendance, Us Weekly reported. Their 12-year-old daughter, Sabine, was photographed at the ceremony.
“We’re very grateful and hopeful,” Shue told USA Today in an October feature announcing his engagement. “I don’t know how it happened, but there’s a happy ending.”

Shue and Fiebig began dating in 2023 after their respective exes, Amy Robach and T.J. Holmes, got together, Page Six reported at the time. The personal lives of both couples entered the spotlight in late 2022 when Robach and Holmes were photographed together while still married to Shue and Fiebig.
Following the scandal, Robach and Holmes left ABC morning news show “GMA3” after a network spokesperson said it was “best for everyone” to “move on.” Holmes and Robach subsequently married in a private ceremony in Arkansas in September.
Shue and Robach were married for 13 years, during which Shue supported her through a stage 2 breast cancer diagnosis. Holmes and Fiebig were also married for 13 years before finalizing their divorces in 2023.
The couple tied the knot on Nov. 2 at their New Jersey country estate, according to TMZ.

Shue was previously married to Amy Robach for 13 years, and Fiebig was married to T.J. Holmes for 13 years.
Fiebig and Holmes share a 12-year-old daughter named Sabine. Shue shares three sons with his first wife, Jennifer Hageney, and Robach shares two daughters with her first husband, Tim McIntosh.
Related reading