Social media platforms are failing to remove fraud and scam content even after members of the public report it, according to a report published by Appeals Centre Europe.
The independent out-of-court dispute settlement body, headquartered in Dublin, examined Facebook, Google Maps, Instagram, Pinterest, Threads, TikTok, and YouTube.
The organisation was established under Article 21 of the European Union’s Digital Services Act. It works alongside Coimisiún na Meán and the European Commission to encourage platforms to implement its decisions. While these rulings are non-binding, platforms must engage with the body in good faith.
The report revealed a trebling in the number of disputes reported this year compared to last year. AI-generated scams are increasingly making it harder for users to distinguish real content from fake material. Over 65,000 disputes have been filed by individuals and organisations across the European Union so far.
“From stealing people’s savings to impacting their mental health, scams destroy lives … Social media should not be a safe haven for scammers,” said Thomas Hughes, CEO of Appeals Centre Europe. “People using social media must have the option to challenge platforms when they fail to enforce their own rules on fraud and scams.”
Surge in Daily Dispute Volume
The organisation received roughly 43,000 disputes during a six-month review period spanning from April to September of this year. That volume amounts to an average of one dispute every 12 minutes, or approximately 200 disputes each day. More than 19,000 of those reports met the criteria for investigation.
Most complaints originated from France, followed by Belgium and Spain. The surge in casework forced the Dublin-based review team to double in size. Five additional staff members joined in recent months, and management is advertising more vacancies to handle the workload.
The report found that platforms frequently break their own rules by leaving prohibited material online. Investigators identified instances of violent or graphic media, hate speech, and content linked to dangerous or criminal organisations remaining active after public reports.
Artificial Intelligence Scams on Major Platforms
Artificial intelligence tools are driving complex financial frauds across multiple networks. An AI-generated romance scam on TikTok featured a woman asking users for money under the guise of seeking a committed relationship. Other TikTok videos blamed climate engineering for the Valencia flash floods and promoted misinformation regarding the Russia-Ukraine war.
Facebook hosted a deepfake video of a Moldovan economic expert promising a 2,000% return on investments. A YouTube video about cryptocurrency instructed viewers to copy a ChatGPT code via a caption link, which could grant scammers access to crypto accounts. Meanwhile, Instagram left up racist comments directed at Black football players following a Champions League match.
Appeals Centre Europe overturned platform decisions in three-quarters of the cases it reviewed. The body disagreed with YouTube in 93% of decisions, TikTok in 77% of cases, Instagram in 75% of reviews, and Facebook in 67% of disputes. It received 17 eligible disputes concerning Pinterest.
Review Body Overturns Many Account Suspension Decisions
Beyond content removal, the organisation processed account suspension disputes outside its core fraud remit. It issued over 8,500 decisions on suspensions, overturning platform choices in roughly a quarter of cases.
Platforms routinely fail to share the underlying content that triggered a suspension, hindering independent reviews. Google proved the most restrictive in this regard. Between October of last year and September of this year, the review body requested more than 850 pieces of content relating to YouTube cases and received only two.
Frequently Asked Questions About the Report
What is Appeals Centre Europe?
Appeals Centre Europe is an independent, out-of-court dispute settlement body based in Dublin. It was set up under Article 21 of the European Union’s Digital Services Act to review content moderation decisions made by major social media platforms.
How many disputes has the centre received?
The organisation has received over 65,000 disputes from individuals and organisations across the European Union. During the six-month period from April to September of this year, it logged roughly 43,000 disputes, averaging 200 cases per day.
Which platform decisions were overturned most frequently?
The body overturned YouTube platform decisions in 93% of the cases it was able to review. It also overturned 77% of TikTok decisions, 75% for Instagram, and 67% for Facebook.
Related reading