Appeals Court Halts Army Detonation Plan at Iowa Plant

“Public communication is essential to public trust,” said Acting Army Secretary Adam Telle, after a federal appeals court halted the Army’s plan to detonate nearly five tons of lead azide at the Iowa Army Ammunition Plant in Middletown.

The Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals granted an administrative stay on the Environmental Protection Agency’s emergency permit late Thursday, pausing a controlled detonation the Army had already rescheduled from Friday to Monday. The permit, issued November 13 and effective through February 11, 2027, authorized in-place destruction of 68 drums of degraded lead azide that officials say has become too unstable to move.

Why the Army Says Detonation Is Necessary

During a March safety review, the Army discovered stored lead azide had dissolved and recrystallized into irregular, highly volatile crystals, increasing sensitivity to friction, shock, and cold temperatures. According to an Army FAQ distributed last month, the material is “extremely unstable and sensitive to even slight friction or movement,” and packing or transporting it “poses an unacceptable risk of accidental detonation.”

Lead azide detonation in Iowa by U.S. Army paused indefinitely — CBS Chicago

The Army modeled four disposal alternatives and concluded that controlled detonation posed the lowest risk to the public, Telle said. The plan called for detonating the drums inside earth-covered concrete magazines surrounded by sand-filled Hesco barriers approximately two stories high, according to CBS News.

EPA Region 7 issued the emergency permit under the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act because the storage location was not covered by the facility’s existing hazardous waste permit.

Army Models Show Lead Plume Reaching Illinois

Army modeling projects surface deposition of lead up to 50 miles northwest of Middletown and airborne exposure as far as 100 miles, reaching parts of western Illinois across the Mississippi River, according to Inside Climate News.

The Army’s projections suggest outdoor lead dust levels in the plume’s path could exceed federal benchmarks for indoor lead levels in homes and childcare facilities, said Patrick O’Shaughnessy, professor of occupational and environmental health at the University of Iowa.

U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
Photo: epa.gov

“There is no safe level of lead in the body,” said Dr. Sameer Vohra, director of the Illinois Department of Public Health. “When inhaled or swallowed, it can pose serious health risks.” Dr. Sameer Vohra warns lead exposure causes serious harm to children’s health, including slowed growth, developmental delays, and problems with learning, behavior, hearing, and speech.

Did You Know? The Iowa Army Ammunition Plant, built in 1941, has never detonated lead azide at this quantity before. “We detonate all the time, but we have not detonated lead azide at this quantity,” said Lori McFate, public affairs specialist with the Army Sustainment Command, to the Chicago Sun-Times.

Why the Army delayed the detonation of lead azide in Iowa — KWQC News

Communication Gaps Draw Bipartisan Criticism

Army officials held a community meeting in Middletown on October 15, but a public advisory last Sunday was the first time communities up to 100 miles away learned of potential impacts, according to AP News.

Middletown Clerk Brieanna Beck said the city of 363 residents had been aware for “about a couple of months” and shared updates on Facebook, but Iowa Governor-elect Rob Sand called the communication “an unacceptable lack of communication and clarity.”

“The Army found out about it many months ago, and then provided residents with a five-day notice,” said Michael Schmidt, general counsel for the Iowa Environmental Council, in a CNN-reported briefing. U.S. Senator-elect Josh Turek and Illinois Governor JB Pritzker both called for delays and greater transparency. Pritzker said he spoke with Telle Friday, urging more data on impacts to Illinois residents.

Cbsn fusion the us wants to detonate unstable explosives in iowa that could affect thousands of americans
Photo: CBS News

Earthjustice Challenges EPA Permit over Cleanup Gaps

Earthjustice filed suit Thursday on behalf of the Iowa Environmental Council and Sierra Club Iowa Chapter, arguing the EPA’s emergency permit lacks adequate cleanup requirements and fails to sufficiently characterize plume spread, including to the Mississippi River. Senior attorney Thien Chau said there “doesn’t appear to be sufficient understanding of how far the plume would spread” or which water bodies and populated areas would be affected.

The EPA indicated in a court filing it would respond by Sunday. The Eighth Circuit’s administrative stay remains in effect while the court considers the emergency motion to halt the detonation. The Army, EPA, and Department of Health and Human Services issued a joint statement Friday affirming they are “prepared to take the most extreme mitigation measures available to ensure there is no risk to the public.”

Federal appeals court blocks the Army’s plan to detonate 9,500 pounds of lead azide in Iowa — WCCO – CBS Minnesota

Weather Window Narrows

Telle said Monday represents the “latest possible moment prior to a forecasted temperature drop, which would risk further destabilization of the material.” The National Weather Service forecasts cooler, drier conditions early next week with highs in the upper 30s to mid-40s and north-to-south winds of 5 to 10 mph, according to CNN meteorologist Chris Dolce. CBS News reported the risk of accidental detonation increases in cold weather.

“The problem should have been evaluated 20 years ago,” O’Shaughnessy told CNN. “Somebody left it to rot that long, for it to now being the only option is to blow it up on site because it can’t be moved.”

Iowa plant sign gty jt hpmain
Photo: ABC News

Questions Answer Lead Azide Risks and Detonation Delays

What is lead azide and why is it at the Iowa Army Ammunition Plant?

Lead azide is a primary explosive used in detonators for munitions. The Army discovered 68 drums stored in bunkers at the Middletown plant had degraded and recrystallized, making them extremely unstable, according to Army officials and the EPA emergency permit.

When was the detonation originally scheduled and why was it postponed?

Two rapid detonations were initially planned for midday Friday, November 20. The Army postponed to Monday, November 23, after public outcry, and the Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals then issued an administrative stay halting the operation entirely while it reviews an emergency motion from environmental groups.

Court indefinitely halts Army's planned detonation of unstable explosives in Iowa — CBS News

What areas could be affected by lead dust from the detonation?

Army modeling projects surface lead deposition up to 50 miles northwest of Middletown and airborne exposure up to 100 miles, potentially reaching parts of western Illinois across the Mississippi River, including the Quad Cities region, according to Inside Climate News and the Chicago Sun-Times.

The Iowa Army Ammunition Plant, established in November 1940 as the Iowa Ordnance Plant, spans 19,011 acres in Des Moines County near the Mississippi River and has produced medium- and large-caliber ammunition for the Department of Defense since 1941. In August 1989, the facility was placed on the National Priorities List after explosives contaminated surface water beyond its boundaries, and a Restoration Advisory Board continues to oversee cleanup activities today.

The court could rule on the emergency motion at any point in the coming days, Chau told Inside Climate News.