Australian musicians and writers have rejected a reported government proposal to exempt the music industry from artificial intelligence training rules while allowing tech companies to scrape other creative works.
The Australian Financial Review reported on Thursday that the Albanese government is considering a copyright change allowing AI companies to buy permits to train on local content, provided music is carved out. The Guardian reported that the music industry and trade unions immediately pushed back against the scheme, calling it an unworkable divide-and-conquer strategy.
The Australian Recording Industry Association and the Australian Writers’ Guild launched a major campaign this week to oppose any weakening of copyright laws. Annabelle Herd, the chief executive of the Australian Recording Industry Association, said the music industry would not desert other creative sectors. Had the industry been consulted, Herd told The Guardian, they would have advised that the scheme was unnecessary and designed to suit commercial tech interests rather than protect creators.
Annabelle Herd and Claire Pullen said that the creative community would remain united in rejecting such changes, with Claire Pullen adding: “I can’t see any creative workers leaving their colleagues behind.” Annabelle Herd mentioned she was unaware of the proposal before Thursday. Claire Pullen also stated: “We have been working with government to come up with a model since 2024.”
Claire Pullen, the CEO of the Australian Writers’ Guild, questioned how complex media like movies or TV shows could be managed if only a single element received an exemption from scraping.
Pullen told The Guardian that the pathway seemed convoluted when AI companies have avoided sitting down to negotiate for years. The Media, Entertainment and Arts Alliance also demanded that any protections promised by the prime minister must apply across all creative fields.
Ministers criticise copyright gaps as tech firms propose deals
Senior government figures have recently pointed to shortfalls in copyright law, with the acting prime minister, Richard Marles, telling News24 on Thursday that people are being ripped off.
The industry minister, Tim Ayres, stated on Tuesday that the status quo is no good for creative workers, while a spokesperson for the attorney general, Michelle Rowland, said the government wants tech companies to strike commercial deals with artists. Meanwhile, companies like Anthropic have suggested conditional approval models, and OpenAI has expressed potential support for paying into a creator fund.
Opposition and crossbench politicians strongly criticized the reported permit plan. The shadow attorney general, Michaelia Cash, claimed the proposal would divide rightsholders and called the tactic ham-fisted. Independent senator David Pocock described the idea as a divide-and-conquer strategy.
The Greens senator Sarah Hanson-Young warned on News24 that Australia could become known as a tax haven for AI if loopholes undermine global copyright standards. Sarah Hanson-Young stated: “Australia will become known as the Cayman Islands for AI if we allow this loophole to happen.” Sarah Hanson-Young also stated: “I say, don’t be that stupid.”
Industry Campaign Details
The broader creative push centers on the Not AI’s To Take campaign, which launched at the ARIA Awards red carpet at Sydney’s Hordern Pavilion. The campaign demands that platforms obtain permission and pay before training on homegrown music, journalism, and art.
Dean Ormston, the CEO of APRA AMCOS, said a mutually beneficial relationship between big tech and creative industries should be a no-brainer. Goldman Sachs’ Music in the Air 2026 report estimates that new monetization ways could add about 10 percent to global recorded music revenues by 2035. Dean Ormston also stated: “No artist should be left to police every copy of their work.”

Campaign urges government to protect copyright
The Not AI’s To Take campaign is an initiative launched by Australian music, creative, and media organizations at the ARIA Awards red carpet in Sydney to urge the federal government to hold the line on copyright protections.
Annabelle Herd, the chief executive of the Australian Recording Industry Association, was appointed to the joint ARIA and PPCA role in January 2021 after a 16-year career at Network 10, where she served as Chief Operating Officer. Her earlier government roles included positions in the Attorney-General’s Department intellectual property branch and as Executive Officer of the Australian Digital Alliance and Australian Libraries Copyright Committee from 1996.
What have senior government ministers said about copyright?
Acting prime minister Richard Marles stated on Thursday that people are being ripped off, industry minister Tim Ayres said the status quo is no good for creative workers, and attorney general Michelle Rowland promised certainty and strong protections for Australian artists.
Worth a look