The Bundesliga table after 15 matchdays can be deceptive, especially this season. Beyond Bayern Munich’s dominance, a fascinating competition for second place is unfolding. A lot can change quickly, and the upcoming clash between Eintracht Frankfurt and Borussia Dortmund marks a crucial restart to the league.
The Paradox of Progress at Borussia Dortmund
Borussia Dortmund’s second-place position feels somewhat fragile, yet it’s a narrative the club is actively embracing. Sporting Director Sebastian Kehl acknowledges they aren’t “100 percent satisfied,” but emphasizes the significant progress made. Captain Emre Can even wonders if this is the club’s strongest first half of a season ever. This internal messaging is a deliberate attempt to build momentum and confidence.
However, the recent past tells a different story. A near-collapse out of Champions League qualification spots and internal squabbles just weeks ago are quickly fading from memory. As Carsten Cramer, the new spokesperson for the executive board, puts it, “Borussia Dortmund has edges and corners, and we have never tried to smooth those edges.” This acceptance of internal friction is a defining characteristic.
Internal Conflicts and External Scrutiny
The club isn’t without its controversies. A public outburst from Serhou Guirassy after a substitution, Karim Adeyemi’s attempt to cover up a weapons charge, and Nico Schlotterbeck’s criticism of teammates all point to a volatile atmosphere. Beyond on-field issues, unresolved allegations of misconduct and a contentious presidential election add to the complexity. The dismissal of the long-serving communications chief, Sascha Fligge, and the outspoken advice from external consultant Matthias Sammer further highlight the internal turmoil.
Sammer’s assessment that parts of the club leadership are “harmony-seeking” – a veiled critique of Kehl – is particularly telling. Cramer’s acceptance of this criticism suggests a willingness to address these issues. The stated goal for 2026 – “to bring the strengths to the forefront” – implies a desire for less public conflict.
The Ruhr Valley Spirit vs. Modern Football
Dortmund’s identity is deeply rooted in the solidarity and collective spirit of the Ruhr Valley. This clashes with the individual ambition and relentless pursuit of success embodied by figures like Sammer and Schlotterbeck. Players like Adeyemi and Guirassy, while talented, sometimes prioritize individual goals over the team’s collective project.
This is where Niko Kovac’s role becomes crucial. He’s proven to be a stabilizing force, navigating these conflicting interests and creating a sense of stability that has been lacking at Dortmund for years. His ability to manage personalities and foster a cohesive environment is a key asset.
Defensive Solidity and Tactical Flexibility
On the pitch, the results speak for themselves. Dortmund has only lost one Bundesliga match – to Bayern Munich – and boasts a remarkably solid defense, conceding just 12 goals in 15 games. Kovac’s tactical flexibility and ability to manage player workload have also contributed to a significant reduction in injuries.
The Future Landscape: Sustainability and Talent Development
Despite the positive momentum, challenges remain. Negotiations with Nico Schlotterbeck regarding a contract extension are ongoing, but his departure to a larger club seems increasingly likely. Questions are also being raised about Sebastian Kehl’s performance as Sporting Director. The squad’s valuation is a concern, and Dortmund has struggled to replace Jude Bellingham with a player of comparable potential.
The “selling club” model, reliant on generating significant transfer profits, is currently proving more successful for rivals like Frankfurt and Leverkusen. Dortmund must fight to maintain its position as Germany’s second-best team, and the current second-place standing carries significant emotional weight.
The Evolving Bundesliga Model
The Dortmund situation reflects a broader trend in the Bundesliga. While Bayern Munich continues to dominate financially, clubs like Leverkusen and Frankfurt are demonstrating that sustainable growth and shrewd player development can challenge the established order. The focus is shifting from simply acquiring star players to building cohesive teams with strong tactical identities. Xabi Alonso’s success at Leverkusen is a prime example of this approach.
The rise of data analytics and sports science is also playing a crucial role. Clubs are increasingly using data to identify undervalued players, optimize training regimes, and prevent injuries. Statista data shows a growing investment in these areas across the league.
The Bundesliga is increasingly embracing data analytics and sports science to gain a competitive edge.
FAQ
Q: Is Borussia Dortmund a genuine title contender?
A: While currently in second place, Dortmund’s consistency and ability to challenge Bayern will be tested in the second half of the season.
Q: What are the biggest challenges facing Dortmund?
A: Maintaining squad depth, replacing key players like Schlotterbeck, and resolving internal conflicts are crucial challenges.
Q: How is the Bundesliga evolving?
A: The league is becoming more competitive, with clubs focusing on sustainable growth, player development, and data-driven decision-making.
What do you think the future holds for Borussia Dortmund? Share your thoughts in the comments below, and explore more Bundesliga analysis on our site. Subscribe to our newsletter for the latest updates and insights.
