Brown University Chemists Prove Relativity Alters Chemical Bonding Rules

“This idea that relativity is important in heavy elements has been around since the 1970s,” Lai-Sheng Wang said.

Chemists at Brown University have overturned a fundamental rule of chemical bonding that has appeared in textbooks for generations. The study, published in the journal Science, reveals that Einstein’s theory of relativity alters chemical bonds when atoms become sufficiently heavy.

Researchers found direct experimental evidence that triple bonds involving heavy elements do not always follow familiar classroom rules. Two types of bonds normally treated as distinct begin to merge, creating a structure that conventional models do not fully describe.

The Brown team used photoelectron spectroscopy to identify relativistic effects in bonds formed between carbon and bismuth. Heavy elements contain nuclei with large numbers of protons, creating electrical attractions that accelerate nearby electrons to a substantial fraction of the speed of light. At these speeds, spin-orbit coupling links quantum spin and orbital motion together.

A story card from The Whole Day: Einstein's Relativity Upends a Fundamental Rule of Chemical Bonding
Photo: thewhole.day

“The boundary between a sigma bond and a pi bond is now sort of smeared,” Wang said. “We still have three bonds, but we don’t really strictly have a sigma or a pi anymore.”

To test this bonding behavior, Wang’s research group, led by Brown Ph.D. students Deniz Kahraman and Jie Hui, created molecules containing carbon and bismuth and cooled them to temperatures approaching absolute zero. The carbon-bismuth triple bonds displayed an electronic structure more consistent with one pi bond and two hybrid sigma-pi bonds.

Brown University found that relativity changes how heavy atoms form triple bonds — Onpode

“But we show direct spectroscopic evidence that what we learned in high school about chemical bonding isn’t true in heavy elements,” Lai-Sheng Wang, a professor of chemistry at Brown and the study’s corresponding author, said.

The findings provide direct experimental confirmation of relativistic bonding effects discussed for decades. Wang believes this evidence could change how chemical bonding is explained in textbooks as research involving heavy elements expands.

Bismuth has attracted scientific interest as a potential less toxic alternative to lead in next-generation solar cells. Researchers are also exploring the element in quantum materials and quantum computing.

Lai-Sheng Wang, a professor of chemistry at Brown University since 2009 and the Jesse H. and Louisa D. Sharpe Metcalf Professor of Chemistry since 2015, has pioneered gas-phase photoelectron spectroscopy of multiply-charged anions and complex molecules. His group developed ion-trap techniques to create ultracold anions enabling high-resolution spectroscopy, and previously uncovered atomic gold pyramids and planar boron clusters including the symmetric B36 structure.

“Maybe this will become the new textbook idea as we are dealing with more and more heavy chemistry of the heavy elements,” Wang said.