Australia’s capital gains tax discount is projected to cost nearly $247 billion over the next decade, a figure exceeding the total cost of the concession over its first 25 years of existence.
The Rising Cost of a Tax Break
New figures from the Parliamentary Budget Office reveal the 50% capital gains tax discount, introduced in 1999, has already cost the budget $205 billion in lost revenue. The escalating cost is driven by Australia’s increasing property prices and continued investor demand.
The figures were commissioned by the Greens party as part of a campaign to pressure the Labor government to reduce the discount. The analysis indicates that the top 1% of taxpayers will benefit from nearly 60% of the discount this financial year, with retirees without taxable income and those earning over $362,900 also receiving significant benefits.
A History of Debate
The capital gains tax discount, often discussed alongside negative gearing rules, has been criticized for incentivizing property investment among wealthier Australians, potentially at the expense of prospective homeowners. Labor previously pledged to reduce the discount during the 2016 and 2019 election campaigns, but was unsuccessful in both bids.
Treasury modeling in 2024 suggested that curbing CGT deductions for investors would have a greater impact on lowering house prices, although it wouldn’t necessarily increase housing supply. Senior Labor figures have indicated openness to changes in the May federal budget, a move supported by the Greens.
What’s Next?
While cabinet ministers have stated there is no current policy change, the possibility of adjustments to the capital gains tax remains on the table. Labor could choose to limit changes to property investors, grandfather existing arrangements, or implement a tiered discount system. A parliamentary inquiry, chaired by Greens senator Nick McKim, is expected to recommend less generous rules for property investors by March 17th. Treasurer Jim Chalmers has expressed a “laser-focus” on intergenerational inequity, suggesting potential tax reforms are under consideration.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the capital gains tax discount?
The 50% capital gains tax discount applies to any investment held for longer than 12 months, reducing the taxable profit when the asset is sold.
Who benefits most from the discount?
According to the Parliamentary Budget Office, the top 1% of taxpayers, as well as retirees without taxable income and individuals earning over $362,900, receive the largest share of the benefits.
Has Labor attempted to change this discount before?
Yes, Federal Labor promised to pare back the discount during the 2016 and 2019 elections, but lost both times to the Coalition.
Given the ongoing debate and upcoming parliamentary inquiry, how might changes to capital gains tax affect the Australian property market and broader economy?
Related reading