The Rising Tide of Crisis Intervention: Rethinking Police Response to Mental Health Emergencies
The recent federal lawsuit filed against the Chattanooga Police Department regarding the death of Roberto Rodriguez Zayas on Christmas Eve underscores a growing national crisis: how law enforcement responds to individuals experiencing mental health emergencies. This case, alleging excessive force in a situation where de-escalation appeared possible, isn’t isolated. It’s part of a disturbing pattern that’s fueling calls for systemic change.
A Nation Grappling with Mental Health and Policing
Across the United States, police officers are increasingly being asked to fill roles they aren’t adequately trained for – acting as first responders to mental health crises. According to the Treatment Advocacy Center, individuals with untreated mental illness are 16 times more likely to be killed during a police encounter. This statistic is particularly stark considering that approximately 1 in 5 U.S. adults experience mental illness each year (National Institute of Mental Health data, 2023). The problem isn’t a lack of compassion on the part of officers, but a lack of specialized training and alternative response options.
The Zayas case highlights several critical points. The lawsuit alleges a failure to de-escalate, a lack of attempts to secure backup trained in crisis intervention, and ultimately, a fatal use of force despite the individual reportedly harming only himself. These are common criticisms leveled against police responses in similar situations.
Did you know? The Memphis Police Department faced similar scrutiny following the death of Tyre Nichols in 2023, a case that also involved a response to a potential mental health crisis and raised questions about police tactics.
The Rise of Alternative Response Models
Fortunately, communities are beginning to explore and implement alternative response models. These programs aim to divert individuals experiencing mental health crises away from the traditional 911 system and connect them with specialized care.
CAHOOTS (Crisis Assistance Helping Out On The Streets) in Eugene, Oregon, is often cited as a pioneering example. For over 30 years, CAHOOTS has dispatched a two-person team – a medic and a crisis worker – to non-violent mental health calls. They handle the majority of these calls without police involvement, resulting in significant cost savings and improved outcomes for individuals in crisis. Data from CAHOOTS shows they handle approximately 24,000 calls annually, with less than 1% requiring police backup.
Other cities are adopting similar approaches. Denver, Colorado, has implemented the STAR (Support Team Assisted Response) program, while New York City is expanding its Mobile Crisis Teams. These teams typically include mental health professionals and peer support specialists, individuals with lived experience of mental illness who can offer empathy and guidance.
Pro Tip: Successful alternative response programs require strong partnerships between law enforcement, mental health agencies, and community organizations. Clear protocols and communication are essential.
The Role of Technology and Training
Beyond alternative response teams, technology and enhanced training are playing an increasingly important role. Body-worn cameras, while not a panacea, can provide valuable documentation of police interactions. More importantly, de-escalation training, crisis intervention training (CIT), and mental health first aid courses are equipping officers with the skills to better assess and respond to individuals in crisis.
CIT, in particular, is gaining traction. This 40-hour training program teaches officers how to recognize the signs and symptoms of mental illness, communicate effectively with individuals in crisis, and connect them with appropriate resources. However, access to CIT varies widely across the country, and many departments still lack adequate funding for comprehensive training.
Legal and Policy Implications
The lawsuit filed in Chattanooga, and others like it, are likely to have significant legal and policy implications. They could lead to increased scrutiny of police practices, stricter guidelines for the use of force, and greater investment in alternative response models. The concept of “qualified immunity,” which shields government officials from liability in certain cases, is also facing increasing challenges in cases involving excessive force and mental health crises. The ACLU provides extensive resources on qualified immunity and police accountability.
Looking Ahead: A Shift in Paradigm
The future of policing and mental health response lies in a fundamental shift in paradigm. We need to move away from a system that relies primarily on law enforcement to address mental health emergencies and toward a system that prioritizes care, compassion, and de-escalation. This requires a commitment to funding alternative response models, expanding access to mental health services, and investing in comprehensive training for law enforcement officers.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Q: What is Crisis Intervention Training (CIT)?
A: CIT is a 40-hour training program for law enforcement officers that teaches them how to recognize and respond to individuals experiencing a mental health crisis.
Q: What is the goal of alternative response programs?
A: The goal is to divert individuals experiencing mental health crises away from the traditional 911 system and connect them with specialized mental health care.
Q: Are alternative response programs effective?
A: Yes, programs like CAHOOTS and STAR have demonstrated significant success in reducing police involvement, improving outcomes for individuals in crisis, and saving costs.
Q: What can I do to support these changes?
A: Advocate for increased funding for mental health services and alternative response programs in your community. Support organizations working to improve police accountability and promote crisis intervention training.
Want to learn more? Explore our other articles on community safety and mental health resources. Subscribe to our newsletter for updates on this important issue.
