China’s Expanding Footprint: Surveillance, Security, and Influence in the Western Balkans
The Western Balkans is rapidly becoming a focal point in a quiet but significant power play. As Chinese investment and tourism surge, so too does Beijing’s reach into the region’s security infrastructure. This isn’t simply about protecting citizens abroad; it’s a complex strategy with implications for individual privacy, national sovereignty, and the broader geopolitical landscape.
The Rise of “Safe Tourist Destination” Programs – A Double-Edged Sword
Joint police patrols, like the “Croatia – Safe Tourist Destination” program, initially appear benign. Billed as measures to safeguard Chinese nationals from fraud and theft, these initiatives are increasingly viewed with suspicion. While Croatian officials tout increased security and a 41% rise in Chinese tourism in 2024, organizations like Safeguard Defenders paint a different picture. Their investigations reveal a network of “overseas police service centers” – some operating with questionable legality – used to “persuade” individuals to return to China, often facing charges that wouldn’t stand up to scrutiny in a Western legal system. This practice, documented in cases involving over 230,000 individuals, raises serious concerns about extrajudicial coercion.
Did you know? The term “persuasion” used by Chinese authorities often masks tactics ranging from harassment of family members in China to outright kidnapping.
Beyond Tourism: Surveillance Technology and the Erosion of Privacy
The security cooperation extends beyond personnel exchanges. Bosnia and Serbia have become prime recipients of Chinese-made surveillance technology – cameras, facial recognition systems, and data analytics tools. These systems, often supplied by companies blacklisted by the US for human rights abuses, are being deployed with limited transparency and oversight. The recent tragedy in Novi Sad, Serbia – a railway station canopy collapse during a project under China’s Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) – highlighted the lack of accountability and the subsequent deployment of even more surveillance technology to monitor protests. A leaked purchase order revealed plans to expand camera coverage by 3500 units, raising fears of a surveillance state in the making.
Transnational Repression: Silencing Dissent Beyond China’s Borders
China’s efforts to control the narrative aren’t limited to physical surveillance. A disturbing trend of transnational repression is emerging, targeting dissidents, activists, and even students studying abroad. The World Uyghur Congress meeting in Sarajevo in October 2024 required heightened security due to threats and intimidation from Chinese nationals monitoring the event. This aligns with China’s broader strategy, outlined in the “guide, buy, and coerce” model, to influence diaspora communities and suppress criticism of the CCP. During Xi Jinping’s foreign trips, protestors have been arrested with questionable legal justification, demonstrating a willingness to stifle dissent even on foreign soil.
Pro Tip: Individuals traveling to or residing in countries with strong Chinese influence should be aware of potential surveillance and take steps to protect their digital privacy, including using encrypted communication tools and VPNs.
The Geopolitical Context: A Strategic Partnership
Serbia’s close relationship with China is rooted in historical grievances – specifically, the 1999 NATO bombing of the Chinese embassy in Belgrade. This event is framed as an act of Western aggression, fostering a sense of solidarity between Belgrade and Beijing. China’s substantial foreign direct investment (FDI) and its willingness to engage without the political conditions attached by the EU further solidify this partnership. Serbia has reciprocated by affirming the One-China policy regarding Taiwan, demonstrating its alignment with Beijing’s geopolitical objectives.
The EU’s Response and Future Trends
The EU faces a complex challenge. While advocating for democratic values and human rights, it also seeks to maintain economic ties with China. A more robust accession strategy for Western Balkan nations, incorporating safeguards against undue Chinese influence, is crucial. This includes promoting transparency in infrastructure projects, strengthening data protection laws, and providing alternative investment opportunities that don’t come with strings attached. However, the EU must also address the underlying vulnerabilities that make these countries susceptible to Chinese influence – namely, their economic dependence and their desire for rapid infrastructure development.
Looking ahead, several trends are likely to emerge:
- Increased Security Cooperation: Expect further expansion of joint police patrols and security agreements between China and Western Balkan nations.
- Proliferation of Surveillance Technology: The deployment of Chinese-made surveillance systems will likely continue, particularly in countries with limited regulatory oversight.
- Growing Transnational Repression: China will likely intensify its efforts to silence dissent and monitor its citizens abroad.
- Digital Silk Road Expansion: China’s Digital Silk Road initiative will continue to promote the adoption of Chinese technology and standards in the region.
- EU Scrutiny and Countermeasures: The EU will likely increase its scrutiny of Chinese investment and implement measures to mitigate its influence.
FAQ
Q: What are “overseas police service centers”?
A: These are unofficial Chinese police stations operating abroad, allegedly for administrative tasks but accused of coercing individuals to return to China.
Q: Is the surveillance technology a security threat?
A: Yes, the technology raises concerns about privacy violations, potential misuse by authoritarian regimes, and the risk of data breaches.
Q: What is the Belt and Road Initiative (BRI)?
A: A global infrastructure development strategy adopted by the Chinese government to invest in over 150 countries and international organizations.
Q: What can the EU do to counter Chinese influence?
A: The EU can offer alternative investment opportunities, strengthen data protection laws, and promote transparency in infrastructure projects.
Reader Question: “How can citizens protect themselves from surveillance in these regions?”
A: Using encrypted communication apps, being mindful of your online activity, and avoiding sharing sensitive information are crucial steps. Supporting organizations that advocate for digital privacy and human rights can also make a difference.
Explore our other articles on geopolitics and digital security to learn more. Subscribe to our newsletter for the latest insights and analysis.
