Cornyn Calls Cruz ‘Fragile Thing’ Over Gaiser Nomination Dispute

Sen. John Cornyn (R-Texas) called fellow Texas Republican Sen. Ted Cruz a “fragile thing” on Saturday as their dispute over a Dallas federal judicial nominee spilled into public view.

The exchange followed a reported shouting match on the Senate floor Friday over President Donald Trump’s nomination of T. Elliot Gaiser to the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Texas. Cornyn blocked the nomination Wednesday by withholding his “blue slip” — the home-state senator’s sign-off that Senate Judiciary Committee Chairman Chuck Grassley (R-Iowa) requires before advancing a district court pick.

Cornyn said Gaiser, a former Ohio solicitor general who leads the Justice Department’s Office of Legal Counsel, lacks Texas ties, trial experience and vetting by the bipartisan Texas judicial screening panel. “If a President can appoint someone from another state, no Senator will have a say in their state, notwithstanding Article II, Section 2, Clause 2 of the U.S. Constitution,” Cornyn posted on X Saturday. “It is called ‘advise and consent.’”

Cruz argued on Fox News that Gaiser’s wife is from Texas and her family lives in Dallas and wanted to return to the state, and that he is the only nominee who can be confirmed before the Senate flips. “All the Republicans agreed, ‘Let’s do everything humanly possible to confirm every judge we can before the end of the year, because we know the Democrats are going to come in January,’” Cruz told anchor Kayleigh McEnany.

Describing the floor confrontation, Cruz said Cornyn began “screaming, he began cursing at me” loudly enough for reporters in the press gallery to hear. The Washington Sun reported Cornyn yelled, “I don’t find you credible. I’m mad at you!” and later, “Oh, that’s bulls—!” before waving Cruz off and walking away.

Cruz linked Cornyn’s anger to his primary loss.

“It is tough in politics when you lose an election,” Cruz said. “That is always hard on anybody, and we’ve got a lot of people who’ve lost their elections who are angry and sometimes, when they’re angry, they last out.”

Trump weighed in Saturday, telling Fox News that Cornyn is doing a “tremendous disservice” by blocking Gaiser. “We’re going to have a radical left lunatic get in there, and we don’t want that,” the president said. Cornyn replied on X: “If President Trump wanted to fill a judicial vacancy in Dallas, why did he wait until after the midterms to nominate someone?” The seat has been vacant since 2025.

Heritage Foundation President Kevin Roberts accused Cornyn of giving Talarico “a head start.” Cornyn shot back on X: “Kevin, your sycophancy has destroyed the credibility of a once great institution, and in so doing you have made yourself irrelevant.”

Cornyn has proposed Fort Worth lawyer Steve Fahey, a former federal prosecutor rated highly by the Texas screening committee, as an alternative.

Sen. Mike Lee (R-Utah) backed Gaiser Friday, writing that “the Senate must confirm Elliott Gaiser — one of America’s most talented lawyers — to the Texas judgeship for which he’s been nominated.” Lee added: “This vacancy exists, we shouldn’t leave it to be filled by Democrats.”

Background on Gaiser and the Senate timeline

Cornyn voted for that confirmation. Gaiser signed a notable Office of Legal Counsel opinion on “disparate impact” this year that moved government policy toward the Supreme Court’s constitutional colorblindness. Senate Republicans have seven weeks, including the Thanksgiving and Christmas recesses, to confirm judges before Democrats take the majority in January.

Additional reactions

Former Rep. Madison Cawthorn (R-N.C.) wrote on social media, “Every time John Cornyn tweets, I thank God President Trump exposed him for the RINO he is.”

John Cornyn’s Blue Slip Decision
Photo: WSJ