Churches across the United States are sparking debate this holiday season by reimagining traditional Nativity scenes to reflect contemporary concerns about immigration enforcement. The displays, which have drawn both support and criticism, prompted a sharp response from the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) on Tuesday.
Nativity Scenes as Protest
Several churches have altered their Nativity scenes to depict the story of Jesus’s birth within the context of current immigration policies. At Lake Street Church in Evanston, Illinois, baby Jesus is portrayed wrapped in a foil blanket, resembling those used in detention facilities, and with zip-tied wrists. Masked figures in green vests labeled “ICE” – representing Immigration and Customs Enforcement – stand guard over the scene, with the Virgin Mary wearing a gas mask. The figure of Joseph was damaged by wind and not replaced, but a sign was erected stating, “Joseph didn’t make it. We hold this space to honor and remember all the victims of immigration enforcement terror.”
Similar displays have appeared in other locations. Urban Village Church near Chicago depicts the Holy Family as “in hiding” due to ICE activity. Oak Lawn United Methodist Church in Dallas shows the Holy Family behind a barbed wire fence, while St. Susanna parish in Dedham, Massachusetts, replaced the figure of Christ with a sign reading, “ICE was here.” A church in Charlotte, North Carolina, features masked ICE agents standing over the traditional scene.
DHS Response
Tricia McLaughlin, assistant secretary for public affairs to DHS, issued a statement to Forbes calling the displays “offensive to Christians” and asserting that depictions of ICE actions, such as zip-tying infants, “NEVER happens.” McLaughlin further stated that such portrayals are contributing to a more than 1,050% increase in assaults on ICE personnel and urged those involved to “get a grip and seek help.”
Rev. Michael Woolf of Lake Street Church told the Associated Press that the scene was created to answer the question, “What would it be like if Jesus were born today in Chicagoland?”
What Might Happen Next
The DHS statement could lead to further polarization of the debate. It is possible that more churches may choose to create similar displays in response, while others may reconsider their approach due to safety concerns or potential legal challenges. The controversy could also fuel further discussion about immigration policy and the role of faith-based organizations in advocating for social change. Depending on the level of public engagement, the issue could become a talking point in upcoming political debates.
Frequently Asked Questions
What prompted these altered Nativity scenes?
A handful of churches across the country have made headlines for depicting what the classic Nativity scene may look like if impacted by modern day Immigration and Customs Enforcement actions.
What was the specific response from the Department of Homeland Security?
A spokesperson for DHS told the clergy leaders to “get a grip and seek help,” stating the scenes were offensive and depicted actions that “NEVER happens,” and contributing to a more than 1,050% increase in assaults on ICE personnel.
Where have these protest Nativities been displayed?
Displays have been reported in Illinois, Massachusetts, Texas, and North Carolina, among other locations.
Given the deeply held beliefs on both sides of this issue, how can communities navigate these sensitive displays in a way that fosters understanding and respect?
