England Rugby on the Brink: Who Could Replace Steve Borthwick?
The pressure is mounting on Steve Borthwick following England’s historic defeat to Italy, a result that has thrown the future of the national team into turmoil. While the Rugby Football Union (RFU) has offered a vote of confidence, many believe a change is inevitable. But who are the contenders to accept the helm?
The Frontrunners: International Experience and Proven Track Records
Scott Robertson: The Razor’s Edge
Scott Robertson, known as “Razor,” is a name frequently surfacing in discussions. Despite a recent power struggle with senior players within the All Blacks setup, his coaching credentials remain impressive. His availability hinges on the terms of his departure from Latest Zealand, a situation complicated by the fact that previous coaching departures haven’t included clauses preventing moves to rival Tier One nations – a lesson learned from the Eddie Jones situation with Australia.
Ronan O’Gara: The Lion’s Roar
Currently contracted to La Rochelle, Ronan O’Gara is a highly sought-after coach. Whispers surrounding his future have been circulating for some time, and he’s considered the favorite to take over the Ireland job should Andy Farrell move on. His ambition to lead an international side is well-known, as evidenced by his comments following Graham Rowntree’s departure from Munster.
Andy Farrell: A Popular Choice, But a Difficult Transition
Andy Farrell’s success with the British & Irish Lions and his current tenure with Ireland make him a popular choice among fans. However, his contract situation with Ireland, expiring after the next World Cup, presents a significant hurdle. Despite potential offers from clubs like Saracens, a move seems unlikely with a major tournament on the horizon.
The Dark Horses: Domestic Success and Untapped Potential
Rob Baxter: A Long-Term Builder
Rob Baxter, known for his dedication to Exeter Chiefs, was previously considered for the role when Eddie Jones was appointed. While he’s recently begun rebuilding the Chiefs, his experience and understanding of the English game would make him a viable option if the RFU prioritizes a domestic coach.
Phil Dowson: Rising Star at Northampton
Phil Dowson has overseen a remarkable turnaround at Northampton Saints, establishing them as a force in the club game. He’s known to harbor ambitions of coaching England, and his recent contract is believed to include an international release clause, positioning him as a strong contender.
Shaun Edwards: Defensive Mastermind
The RFU previously missed opportunities to secure Shaun Edwards, who is currently with France. A proven winner and highly respected defensive coach, Edwards could be a transformative appointment, though extracting him from his current deal may prove challenging.
Outside Bets: Experience and Alternative Options
Johann Van Graan: Trophy Winner with Bath
Johann Van Graan has successfully transformed Bath into a trophy-winning team, a feat that has earned him recognition. He’s also been earmarked as a potential future Springboks coach, which could influence his decision-making process.
Jamie Joseph: A Close Call with the All Blacks
Jamie Joseph was a finalist for the All Blacks coaching position, demonstrating his capabilities on the international stage. While considered a rank outsider, he could be a dark horse candidate.
Michael Cheika: NRL Bound, But Still a Contender?
Michael Cheika’s pedigree is undeniable, but his current role in the NRL may make a move to England rugby a year too late.
John Mitchell: An Internal Solution?
Currently employed by the RFU with the Red Roses, John Mitchell could be a cost-effective option, avoiding the require for compensation payments.
Jake White: World Cup Winner Seeking a Return
A former Rugby World Cup winner with the Springboks, Jake White is actively seeking a coaching position and could bring valuable experience to the England setup.
FAQ
Who is the favorite to replace Steve Borthwick?
Currently, Ronan O’Gara appears to be the frontrunner, followed closely by Scott Robertson.
Could Andy Farrell leave Ireland to coach England?
It’s unlikely, given his contract with Ireland and the upcoming World Cup.
Are any domestic coaches in contention?
Yes, Rob Baxter and Phil Dowson are both considered viable options.
What is Scott Robertson’s situation with the All Blacks?
He experienced a power struggle with senior players, and his availability depends on the terms of his departure.
Did you know? Shaun Edwards was a missed opportunity for the RFU on multiple occasions.
Don’t agree with our assessment? Let us know your thoughts in the comments below! Explore more articles on RugbyPass to stay up-to-date with the latest news, and analysis.
