The Post-Hype Sleeper: Why Forgotten Fantasy Players Could Win You a League
In the world of fantasy sports, we’re constantly chasing the next breakout star. We pore over metrics, seeking players poised for a leap. But what about those who were hyped, then faded? These “post-hype” players, often overlooked in drafts, can be league-winning steals. They represent a unique opportunity to capitalize on undervalued talent.
What Defines a Post-Hype Sleeper?
A post-hype player isn’t simply someone who had a disappointing season. They’re individuals who once carried significant prospect status or generated buzz but failed to live up to expectations. Crucially, they’re currently being drafted outside the top 200 picks, meaning they aren’t guaranteed to outperform their draft value, but possess the potential to do so.
Spotlight on Potential 2026 Breakouts
Brett Baty – 2B/3B, New York Mets (ADP: 280)
Despite ongoing discussion about his talent, Brett Baty is currently being drafted relatively late. His struggles to secure consistent playing time are a concern, but a change in approach at the plate in 2025 – increased patience, improved barrel rate, and higher exit velocity – suggests a potential breakout. He could be the starting designated hitter against right-handed pitching, with the versatility to play second or third base.
Evan Carter – OF, Texas Rangers (ADP: 285)
Carter’s impressive 2023 debut fueled high expectations, but injuries derailed his progress. Back issues plagued him, and a broken wrist further hampered his development. However, a lumbar ablation procedure to address his back problems, combined with a revamped swing, offers a glimmer of hope. He showed promising signs in the second half of 2025, with a .263 average, four home runs, and 11 steals in 50 games.
Chase DeLauter – OF, Cleveland Guardians (ADP: 302)
Injuries have consistently derailed DeLauter’s career, preventing him from reaching his potential as a top prospect. Despite limited playing time, he’s demonstrated strong contact skills and power potential. If he can stay healthy, he could become the Guardians’ starting center fielder and provide a solid offensive contribution.
Jordan Lawlar – 3B, Arizona Diamondbacks (ADP: 322)
Lawlar’s path to consistent playing time has been blocked by injuries. Hamstring issues have limited his opportunities, but his performance in Triple-A suggests significant upside. A potential opportunity to win a starting job in the outfield could finally unlock his potential, offering a combination of power and speed.
Jordan Walker – OF, St. Louis Cardinals (ADP: 324)
Walker has struggled to adapt to MLB pitching, but improvements in his swing mechanics and a focus on pulling the ball could lead to a breakout. The Cardinals’ commitment to player development and a potential opportunity for regular playing time make him an intriguing late-round pick.
Bo Naylor – C, Colorado Rockies (ADP: 361)
Naylor’s career numbers are underwhelming, but his underlying skills suggest potential. He possesses good raw power and has shown a willingness to adjust his approach at the plate. A move to the Rockies, known for its hitter-friendly environment, could unlock his offensive capabilities.
Triston Casas – 1B, Colorado Rockies (ADP: 385)
Casas has been hampered by freak injuries, but his career .800 OPS and solid batted ball metrics indicate underlying talent. A change of scenery to the Rockies, combined with a potential adjustment to his approach, could lead to a resurgence.
Jacob Melton – OF, Tampa Bay Rays (ADP: 410)
Melton has a chance to earn a starting role with the Rays, showcasing his strong contact skills and speed. The Rays’ track record of player development could help him maximize his potential.
Parker Meadows – OF, Detroit Tigers (ADP: UNDRAFTED)
Despite past struggles, Meadows has demonstrated a strong perceive for the strike zone and the potential to steal bases. A return to form could make him a valuable asset in deeper leagues.
Eduoard Julien – 2B, Colorado Rockies (ADP: UNDRAFTED)
Julien’s high strikeout rate is a concern, but his solid contact skills and power potential could thrive in the hitter-friendly environment of Coors Field. A change in approach could unlock his offensive capabilities.
Why Target Post-Hype Players?
Drafting post-hype sleepers isn’t about finding guaranteed stars. It’s about identifying players with the skills to succeed who are being undervalued due to recent struggles or perceived limitations. These players offer a high-risk, high-reward proposition that can give your fantasy team a significant edge.
FAQ
Q: What is ADP?
A: ADP stands for Average Draft Position. It indicates where a player is typically drafted in fantasy leagues.
Q: Are post-hype sleepers always successful?
A: No. They are a higher-risk pick, and many will not live up to their potential.
Q: How much should I rely on post-hype sleepers?
A: Don’t build your entire team around them. Use them as strategic late-round picks to add upside to your roster.
Did you know? Players drafted outside the top 200 often have the highest potential for return on investment.
Pro Tip: Pay attention to changes in a player’s approach or swing mechanics. These adjustments can be indicators of a potential turnaround.
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to gain a competitive edge in your fantasy league. Explore more draft strategies and player analysis on our site. Click here to learn more!
