Fox News Host’s Polygraph Proposal Sparks Debate in Missing Person Case
Fox News host Greg Gutfeld has ignited controversy by suggesting Savannah Guthrie, co-anchor of NBC’s “Today” show, undergo a polygraph examination in connection with the disappearance of her 84-year-ancient mother, Nancy Guthrie. The case, which began on January 31st with Nancy Guthrie vanishing from her Tucson home, has drawn international attention, particularly after the only person initially held was released.
Gutfeld’s Rationale and Criticism
Gutfeld proposed the polygraph during a segment on “The Five,” arguing it could pressure others connected to the case to also submit to lie detector tests. “I want to revisit my strategy to solving this case, and that would be having the least likely suspect, Savannah Guthrie, offer to do a polygraph, which will then put necessary pressure on others inside and outside the circle to do the same,” he stated. He believes that anyone declining the test would appear suspicious.
This suggestion has been met with significant backlash. Critics argue it’s insensitive to suggest such a measure although a search is underway and there’s no indication of family involvement. The Decoding Fox News account on X (formerly Twitter) described Gutfeld’s comments as “childish” and “inappropriate,” highlighting the seriousness of the situation. Author Joyce Carol Oates responded with a pointed question, suggesting Fox News personalities, including Gutfeld, should be subjected to polygraphs themselves.
The Investigation and Emerging Leads
The FBI is currently investigating the disappearance, and has released images of a masked individual seen at Nancy Guthrie’s door. A glove, potentially belonging to the person in the images, was discovered approximately 1.5 miles from the Guthrie residence. Investigators are analyzing the glove for potential DNA evidence.
A latest ransom note has surfaced, demanding 1 Bitcoin (currently valued around $67,500) for information about the individual involved. This demand is only slightly higher than the $50,000 reward offered by the FBI for information leading to Nancy Guthrie’s recovery or the arrest of those responsible.
The Role of Polygraphs in Investigations
While Gutfeld suggests a polygraph could be a valuable tool, it’s important to note their limitations. As Paul Mauro, a former NYPD inspector and Fox News contributor, pointed out, polygraph results are not admissible in court. However, they can sometimes serve as an investigative pointer, potentially prompting further questioning or investigation.
The Ethics of Public Pressure in Missing Person Cases
Gutfeld’s call for Guthrie to voluntarily submit to a polygraph raises ethical questions about the role of media and public pressure in ongoing investigations. While public awareness can be helpful, some argue that speculation and demands for specific actions can hinder law enforcement efforts and cause undue distress to families.
The Impact of Media Coverage
The intense media focus on this case, particularly from Fox News, has been noted. Decoding Fox News observed that the network has dedicated significant coverage to the story for two weeks. This level of attention can amplify public interest but also potentially complicate the investigation.
FAQ
Q: Are polygraph tests accurate?
A: Polygraph tests are not considered foolproof and are often debated in terms of their accuracy. Results are not typically admissible in court.
Q: What is the current status of the investigation?
A: The FBI is actively investigating, analyzing evidence such as a recovered glove and pursuing leads related to a new ransom note.
Q: Has Nancy Guthrie been found?
A: As of February 14, 2026, Nancy Guthrie remains missing.
Q: What is 1 Bitcoin worth?
A: As of February 14, 2026, 1 Bitcoin is worth approximately $67,500.
Did you know? The FBI is seeking ring camera footage from residents in the area surrounding Nancy Guthrie’s home to aid in the investigation.
Pro Tip: If you have any information regarding the disappearance of Nancy Guthrie, contact the FBI immediately.
Stay informed about this developing story and other important news. Explore more articles on our website or subscribe to our newsletter for the latest updates.
