Canadian Pension Funds Navigate a Shifting Private Equity Landscape
Canada’s pension funds, long considered sophisticated investors in private equity, are facing a challenging environment. Recent performance reports reveal significant headwinds, prompting a re-evaluation of strategies and a potential shift in asset allocation.
Private Equity Returns Under Pressure
Several of Canada’s largest pension funds experienced negative returns on their private equity portfolios in 2025. Ontario Teachers’ Pension Plan reported a -5.3% return, although the Ontario Municipal Employees Retirement System (OMERS) saw a -2.5% decline. These represent the worst performances for OTPP since 2009 and for OMERS since 2020, respectively. La Caisse de dépôt et placement du Québec, with C$517 billion under management, achieved a 2.3% return, falling short of its benchmark index’s 12.6% gain.
The Healthcare of Ontario Pension Plan reported a slightly better 3.6% return in private equity, with its broader private markets portfolio returning 2.1% compared to 11.7% for listed holdings.
Rising interest rates since 2022 are a key factor, increasing borrowing costs and impacting dealmaking, returns, and exit opportunities. Some private equity funds have been more affected than others.
A Broader Trend: Rethinking Private Equity Models
This downturn isn’t isolated. Canadian pension funds, collectively overseeing $1.2 trillion, are revamping their private equity models. The system holds over $400 billion in private equity assets, representing more than 20% of public sector pension money.
Dale Burgess, Executive Managing Director of Equities at OTPP, noted that investors are “navigating increased cost of capital, more constrained exit markets and greater operating complexity, creating a drag on returns.”
Private Credit Funds Face Redemption Requests
Beyond private equity, the broader private credit market is also experiencing turbulence. Wealthy investors have sought to pull more than $10 billion from some of the largest private credit funds in the first quarter, leading managers like Blackstone, BlackRock, and Cliffwater to limit withdrawals.
While these funds manage roughly $166 billion, the redemptions reverse a five-year trend of nearly $200 billion in inflows. Some on Wall Street have drawn parallels to the early stages of the 2008 financial crisis.
The Rise of Short-Term Crypto Bets
Amidst these shifts in traditional private markets, retail investors are increasingly drawn to short-term cryptocurrency bets. Contracts on whether the price of Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies will rise or fall in five or 15 minutes are attracting approximately $70 million in daily trading volume across Polymarket and Kalshi.
These ultra-short-term contracts now represent over half of all crypto trading on both platforms, creating new arbitrage opportunities for high-speed trading firms.
Navigating the New Landscape
The current environment demands a more cautious and strategic approach to private market investments. Pension funds are likely to focus on higher-quality assets, prioritize operational improvements within portfolio companies, and potentially reduce their exposure to riskier segments of the private equity market.
Pro Tip:
Diversification remains key. While private equity can offer attractive returns, it’s crucial to balance these investments with more liquid assets and a broader portfolio strategy.
FAQ
Q: What is driving the decline in private equity returns?
A: Rising interest rates, constrained exit markets, and increased operating complexity are all contributing factors.
Q: Are Canadian pension funds reducing their private equity holdings?
A: Some funds are shifting holdings, but a complete reduction isn’t necessarily the case. They are revamping their models and focusing on quality.
Q: What is the impact of redemptions in private credit funds?
A: Redemptions are putting pressure on fund managers and potentially stalling growth in this sector.
Q: What are the risks associated with short-term crypto bets?
A: These bets are highly speculative and carry significant risk due to the volatility of the cryptocurrency market.
Did you know? Aardman Animations, the creators of Wallace & Gromit, are celebrating their 50th anniversary this year with an exhibition at the Young V&A in London.
Explore more insights into asset management and investment strategies. Subscribe to FT Asset Management for weekly updates.
