The Return of “Good Stupid Fun”: Why Unpretentious Comedy is Making a Comeback
Last summer’s unexpected theatrical success of The Naked Gun revival signaled something important: audiences are craving genuine, unadulterated laughter. In a landscape dominated by meme-driven humor and self-aware blockbusters, the simple joy of a truly funny movie felt revolutionary. This sentiment is echoed in the positive reception of David Wain’s latest, Gail Daughtry and the Celebrity Sex Pass, a film described as “good stupid fun.” But is this a fleeting trend, or a sign of a larger shift in comedic tastes?
The Fatigue of Irony and the Rise of Sincerity
For decades, irony has been the dominant mode of comedy. Shows like The Simpsons (in its golden age) and films by directors like Quentin Tarantino perfected the art of the knowing wink, the self-referential joke. However, a growing number of viewers are experiencing “irony fatigue.” A 2023 study by Nielsen showed a slight dip in viewership for heavily ironic comedies, while more straightforward, character-driven humor saw a modest increase. People are looking for escapism, for a release from the constant cynicism of modern life. They want to *feel* something, even if that something is just pure, unadulterated silliness.
This aligns with a broader cultural trend towards sincerity. Social media, once a breeding ground for irony, is increasingly populated with authentic self-expression. The rise of “beReal” and the popularity of unfiltered content demonstrate a desire for genuine connection, a desire that extends to entertainment.
The Wain/Marino Model: Absurdity with Heart
David Wain and Ken Marino represent a particularly potent strain of this return to sincerity. Their work, from Wet Hot American Summer to Gail Daughtry, isn’t about deconstructing comedy; it’s about embracing it. It’s goofy, often edgy, and rarely concerned with making a profound statement. Instead, it prioritizes creating a joyful, immersive experience for the audience.
This approach is proving influential. We’re seeing a surge in independent comedies that prioritize character and absurdity over cleverness. Films like Barb and Star vs. the Evil Queen (2021) and the work of Bo Burnham, while possessing unique styles, share a similar willingness to be unapologetically silly.
Pro Tip: Don’t underestimate the power of commitment. The most successful “dumb” comedies aren’t afraid to fully embrace their own absurdity. Half-hearted attempts at silliness often fall flat.
The Streaming Effect: Niche Audiences and Creative Freedom
The rise of streaming services has been crucial to this trend. Traditional Hollywood studios are often risk-averse, prioritizing blockbuster potential over niche appeal. Streaming platforms, however, are more willing to experiment with unconventional comedies, knowing they can find a dedicated audience even if the film doesn’t appeal to the masses.
This allows filmmakers like Wain and Marino to operate with greater creative freedom. They aren’t forced to compromise their vision to appeal to a broader demographic. This freedom is reflected in the unique, idiosyncratic humor of their films.
The Future of Funny: What to Expect
Several trends suggest that unpretentious comedy will continue to gain traction:
- Increased Demand for Escapism: As the world becomes increasingly complex and stressful, the demand for lighthearted entertainment will only grow.
- The Power of Nostalgia: Many viewers are nostalgic for the comedies of their youth – films like Airplane! and Animal House – and are eager to see a return to that style of humor.
- The Rise of Alternative Comedy: Platforms like TikTok and YouTube are fostering a new generation of comedians who are pushing the boundaries of the genre, often embracing absurdity and silliness.
- Genre Blending: Expect to see more comedies that blend genres, incorporating elements of horror, sci-fi, or fantasy to create unique and unexpected comedic experiences.
Did you know? The success of The Naked Gun revival demonstrates that even established franchises can benefit from embracing a more straightforward comedic approach. The film’s humor relies on slapstick, visual gags, and Leslie Nielsen’s deadpan delivery, rather than meta-commentary or irony.
FAQ: The Future of Comedy
- Is irony dead? Not entirely, but its dominance is waning. Audiences are seeking a balance between irony and sincerity.
- Will “dumb” comedies become mainstream? Probably not, but they will continue to find a dedicated audience, particularly on streaming platforms.
- What makes a good “dumb” comedy? Commitment to the bit, strong characters, and a willingness to embrace absurdity.
- Are there any emerging comedic voices to watch? Keep an eye on filmmakers and comedians who are prioritizing character-driven humor and unconventional storytelling.
The future of comedy isn’t about abandoning intelligence or sophistication. It’s about recognizing that sometimes, the most satisfying thing is to simply laugh. It’s about embracing the power of “good stupid fun” and allowing audiences to escape, even for just 90 minutes.
Want to explore more about the changing landscape of comedy? Read our article on the impact of TikTok on comedic trends or subscribe to our newsletter for the latest insights.
