As the New York Giants weigh a blockbuster trade for Indianapolis Colts running back Jonathan Taylor ahead of the November 10 deadline, football analysts and insiders debate whether acquiring the playmaker fits the NFC East leader’s current timeline or repeats past roster mistakes.
Jonathan Taylor Trade Interest Draws Sharp Fan and Analyst Divide
The New York Giants sit atop the NFC East with a 4-2-1 record entering their bye week, drawing heavy trade speculation as the November 10 deadline approaches. Among the most prominent names linked to the franchise is Indianapolis Colts running back Jonathan Taylor, who has emerged on the trade market after Indianapolis signaled a willingness to deal the 27-year-old, according to reports. Albert Breer reported that the Giants and Minnesota Vikings have been the most aggressive teams in running back trade discussions.
Fans and observers quickly pushed back against that assessment. Others pointed to the franchise’s turbulent recent history as a reason to seize the moment.
Remember the ‘ahead of schedule’ 2022 Giants. Future looked bright. Daboll/Schoen were superstars. Next 3 years were trash. Stop worrying so much about draft picks. Add good players.
Joe Schoen and Front Office Weigh Roster Needs Against Draft Capital
Giants general manager Joe Schoen addressed the team’s trade deadline approach during his bye week press conference, emphasizing that management will evaluate both short-term performance and long-term asset management. Schoen acknowledged that the team lacks premium draft capital, noting the Giants do not have a fourth- or a fifth-round pick in 2027.
Despite missing starting quarterback Jaxson Dart and top edge rusher Brian Burns to season-ending injuries, Schoen insisted those losses will not dictate the front office’s deadline strategy. That really doesn’t affect us now,
Schoen said Tuesday. We are where we are, and we were 1-0 with Jaxson … and obviously J.J. (McCarthy) is our starter now. That really won’t impact what we do.
Running back depth became an immediate talking point when backup Tyrone Tracy Jr. suffered a hamstring injury in the second quarter of a 27-21 overtime victory against the Houston Texans. Schoen announced that Tracy will be placed on injured reserve, though the injury is not expected to end his season. The team also holds running back Phil Mafah on the practice squad, maintaining a running back room that includes Cam Skattebo and Devin Singletary.
Alternative Trade Targets and Pivot Options on the Market
While Jonathan Taylor commands massive attention—with the Colts reportedly rejecting an offer that included a 2027 second-round draft pick—other options remain on the radar for New York’s front office. Jacksonville Jaguars wide receiver Brian Thomas Jr. represents a potential target given his limited offensive usage this season, which could provide a weapon. Meanwhile, it was noted that Baltimore Ravens running back Derrick Henry could become available as Baltimore navigates season-ending thumb and toe injuries to quarterbacks Lamar Jackson and Tyler Huntley.
Henry carries a $12 million non-guaranteed salary for 2027 and leads the league with 158 carries for 632 yards and eight touchdowns through eight games. The connection to New York’s coaching staff is apparent; after a Week 5 loss, head coach John Harbaugh expressed a desire for a traditional bell-cow runner. I would love for us to be in that kind of a circumstance,
Harbaugh said at the time, referencing A Derrick Henry circumstance or a Saquon Barkley circumstance.
Defensive interior help also remains a priority for the front office behind veterans Shelby Harris and D.J. Reader. Analysts have floated potential reunions with players such as Chargers defensive tackle Dalvin Tomlinson, who has started 146 career games. With the November 10 deadline approaching, Schoen and Harbaugh have time to determine whether to invest premium assets into a blockbuster addition or protect future draft capital.
Worth a look