A Hastings District Council councillor, Steve Gibson, did not attend a recent strategic planning session held at Waiohiki Marae, citing concerns about the process, timing, and the nature of the meeting itself.
Concerns Raised Over Marae Venue
Gibson stated his discomfort stemmed from two primary issues. He expressed concern over extended addresses delivered in te reo Māori without translation, particularly given that not all councillors are fluent. He also noted that the spiritual aspects of the marae, which he said were inconsistent with his Christian faith, created an uncomfortable environment for him to conduct council business.
Mayor Wendy Schollum explained that council sessions are frequently held in various community venues, including halls, marae, and function centres, to foster connections with diverse communities. She indicated that the venue was discussed in December, with Waiohiki Marae suggested as an alternative to Keirunga Homestead, and no objections were raised at the time.
Purpose of the Session
According to Schollum, these sessions are designed to allow councillors to collectively discuss the high-level direction of the council, informing the development of the Long Term Plan. Councillors are encouraged to share perspectives and consider responsible long-term decision-making. She emphasized that these forums focus on setting direction, not making specific project decisions.
Gibson defended his decision, stating that a stand is sometimes necessary to achieve better governance. He suggested the session’s structure appeared to prioritize conformity over open debate. He also drew a parallel, stating he would not expect councillors to attend meetings held in a religious setting promoting doctrines he disagreed with.
Schollum noted that attendance at these sessions is strongly advised but ultimately a matter of individual choice for councillors, who are not considered employees of the council. Takitimu Māori ward councillor Heather Te Au-Skipworth stated that those in attendance were welcomed with “aroha and manaaki” by the marae’s representatives.
Separately, the council’s chief executive, Nigel Bickle, appointed a private investigator in December 2025 to examine allegations regarding Gibson’s conduct at the Hastings Art Gallery on December 5. A preliminary assessment has been completed, and the Mayor will determine the next steps.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why was the session held at a marae?
Mayor Wendy Schollum stated that these sessions are often held in community venues, including marae, to connect with the council’s varied communities. The session was suggested as an alternative to Keirunga Homestead, and no objections were raised.
What was Steve Gibson’s primary concern?
Steve Gibson expressed discomfort with extended addresses delivered in te reo Māori without translation and with the spiritual aspects of the marae, which he stated were inconsistent with his Christian faith.
Is attendance at these sessions mandatory for councillors?
No, according to Mayor Wendy Schollum, councillors are not employees of the council and the decision to attend is up to them as individuals, although attendance is strongly advised.
How might differing perspectives on inclusive practices shape future council decisions?
