A homeowner returned from Shanghai on October 21 to discover her 20-year-old hybrid coconut tree in the Holland area had been chopped down without her knowledge or consent, according to reports from stomp.sg and news.nestia.com.
Permit Issued Two Years Prior Sparks Dispute in Holland Gardens
When the resident confronted the situation, the contractor produced a permit dated September 12, 2024, granting permission for the works. The property owner, identified as Lee by stomp.sg and Stephanie by news.nestia.com, stated that she received no notice regarding the removal during the two years following the permit’s issuance. The tree, which did not grow excessively tall due to its hybrid nature, was planted in the early 2000s and stood near her gate within her boundary. She told stomp.sg that her next-door neighbour shifted the neighbouring gate close to her boundary wall for fengshui reasons before moving out to redevelop the property.
Sentiment and Shade Lost After Decades of Growth
The coconut tree provided shade and regularly produced fruit that the resident shared with sanitation workers, while local wildlife such as squirrels frequented the branches. “It is a hybrid and special type of tree that does not grow too tall, so it is easy to pluck the fruits,” the resident told stomp.sg, adding that grandchildren enjoyed watching the animals. She expressed frustration that the architect or neighbour did not notify her earlier to allow her to transplant the tree into her own garden before construction reached its final stages.
National Parks Board Explores Replacement Options
According to screenshots reviewed by stomp.sg, the National Parks Board (NParks) informed the resident that it had contacted the contractor to discuss planting a replacement coconut tree on her property. As of October 28, the resident stated she had not received a satisfactory resolution and intended to speak with authorities and her Member of Parliament. Stomp.sg reported that NParks was contacted for further information regarding the approval process.
Common Questions About the Holland Area Tree Removal
When did the homeowner discover the tree was removed?
The resident discovered the tree was missing upon returning home from Shanghai on October 21, according to stomp.sg.
What date was the removal permit issued?
The contractor’s permit allowing the works was dated Sept 12, 2024, more than two years ago.
What solution has NParks proposed?
NParks reached out to the contractor to explore the possibility of planting a replacement coconut tree within the resident’s premises, based on screenshots seen by stomp.sg.
Related reading