Illinois Senate Race: Immigration and the Future of ICE
Immigration enforcement is a central issue in the 2026 Illinois Senate campaign, with candidates sharply divided on the path forward. Democrats vying for the nomination to replace Senator Dick Durbin disagree on whether to abolish ICE or reform the agency, while Republicans debate continuing or modifying the policies of President Donald Trump.
Republican Candidates: Enforcement and Border Security
Republican candidates generally emphasize stricter border control and enforcement of existing immigration laws. Casey Chlebek proposes a complete overhaul of the immigration system, suggesting “recruitment centers” abroad to pre-screen potential immigrants based on national needs. He believes the current system is failing and contributing to a surge in undocumented immigrants.
Jeannie Evans advocates for cooperation between federal, state, and local authorities to enforce immigration laws. She supports federal funding for Illinois and believes the state should work *with* the federal government, not resist it.
Don Tracy strongly supports closing the borders and enforcing immigration law, citing examples from Memphis, Tennessee, where increased federal enforcement led to numerous arrests and the seizure of illegal firearms. He criticizes instances where local authorities hinder federal operations, leading to “chaos,” as seen in Chicago and Minneapolis.
Democratic Candidates: Reform or Abolition of ICE
Among the Democratic candidates, a significant debate centers on the future of ICE. Robin Kelly calls for the complete dismantling of ICE, arguing it’s part of a larger systemic problem within the Department of Homeland Security. She points to the actions of the Border Patrol, not ICE, in the shooting death of Alex Pretti in Minneapolis as evidence of broader issues.
Raja Krishnamoorthi takes a firm stance against funding the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) under its current structure. He demands changes including the removal of masks by agents, the use of body cameras, visible identification, an end to warrantless detentions, and independent investigations into the use of force.
Juliana Stratton also advocates for abolishing ICE, stating the agency, as currently operated, is not focused on immigration or public safety. She proposes a comprehensive overhaul of the system, investing in immigration judges, community resources, and pathways to legal citizenship.
The Debate Over ICE’s Role
The differing viewpoints highlight a fundamental disagreement about the role of federal immigration enforcement. Democrats increasingly question the effectiveness and morality of ICE’s tactics, while Republicans prioritize border security and the enforcement of existing laws. The candidates’ positions reflect a broader national conversation about immigration policy and the balance between security and humanitarian concerns.
Recent ICE Actions and Oversight Concerns
Senator Dick Durbin has repeatedly criticized ICE’s actions in Illinois, describing them as “terrible, indefensible, and embarrassing.” He was denied entry into the Broadview ICE detention center on multiple occasions, raising concerns about transparency and oversight. In January 2026, Durbin decried ICE’s actions as a “reign of terror” but stopped short of committing to vote against a federal spending package that included funding for the agency.
Data released by Durbin indicates that of over 600 people detained by ICE in Chicago, only 16 had criminal histories, further fueling concerns about the agency’s focus.
FAQ
Q: What is the main point of contention regarding ICE?
A: The debate centers on whether ICE should be abolished, reformed, or continue operating as it currently does.
Q: What are Republicans proposing regarding immigration enforcement?
A: Republicans generally advocate for stricter border control, enforcement of existing laws, and cooperation between federal, state, and local authorities.
Q: What concerns have been raised about ICE’s operations?
A: Concerns include the use of excessive force, lack of transparency, and the detention of individuals with no criminal history.
Pro Tip
Stay informed about the candidates’ positions on immigration by visiting their official campaign websites and attending town hall meetings.
Did you grasp? Illinois Senators Dick Durbin and Tammy Duckworth are joining a group of colleagues who say they won’t pass a funding bill without reforms to ICE and other agencies.
Explore further: Read Senator Durbin’s statement on ICE enforcement in Illinois.
What are your thoughts on the future of ICE? Share your opinion in the comments below!
