Judge William Sullivan has scheduled a retrial for Lindsay Clancy to begin on March 29, 2027, following a deadlocked jury in her initial murder trial.
“The die has been cast,” Kevin Reddington, the defense attorney for Clancy, told Judge Sullivan during Monday’s hearing. He suggested that the prosecution's insistence on a jury trial indirectly indicates that the district attorney intends to proceed with first-degree murder indictments.
Judge sets March trial date despite unconfirmed charges
The court set the March date on Monday despite the Plymouth County District Attorney’s office not yet confirming the specific charges for the upcoming proceedings. Prosecutors had initially requested a May trial date, citing scheduling conflicts, but the judge opted for the earlier March 29 start. Prosecutors have not clarified if they will again pursue first-degree murder charges or opt for lesser counts, such as second-degree murder or manslaughter.
“The ball is in Mr. Cruz's court,” defense attorney Kevin Reddington said at the hearing.
Lindsay Clancy 🧵 Media just shuffled into the courtroom. Reddington and Laura McConnell are present for Clancy. Her parents aren’t here. Jen Sprague and Shannon Buckingham just walked in.
Assistant District Attorney Jennifer Sprague told the court that prosecutors were “ready to pick a jury trial date,” according to PBS. Defense attorney Kevin Reddington interpreted this stance as a clear signal of the state’s intent.
“I think you can read between the lines that when they say that the case is going to require a jury, that it’s an indirect comment from the DA that they intend to proceed on first-degree murder indictments,” Reddington told Judge Sullivan.
Clancy, has remained publicly silent about his plans since the mistrial. Clancy should be found not guilty by reason of insanity.
Indication is prosecution does not intend to drop 1st degree murder charges against Lindsay Clancy. That is indicated by them saying they want to pick a date for a jury trial.
Did You Know? During the first trial, jurors visited the Duxbury home where the children died to gain a firsthand view of the scene.
Defense appeals refusal to dismiss the case
Clancy’s defense team recently filed an appeal with the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court, seeking to overturn Judge Sullivan’s refusal to dismiss the case. The defense argues that the first trial’s mistrial could have been avoided had the judge investigated the conduct of a lone holdout juror who refused to join the other 11 jurors in an acquittal.
The defense team stated in its motion that a more thorough examination of his conduct might have provided grounds for discharging the juror and replacing him with an alternate.
Lindsay Clancy hearing starting now. Prosecutor says they are ready to "pick a jury trial date."
Reddington had previously requested an inquiry into that juror, alleging he failed to disclose past criminal charges during the selection process. Heather O’Connor, an attorney representing the juror, stated he “believed he was truthful” on his questionnaire.
Judge Sullivan denied these motions, ruling that further investigation would be “impermissibly coercive.” Sullivan also rejected a defense request to dismiss the charges on double jeopardy grounds, ruling that a retrial would not violate constitutional protections.
If the prosecution pursues first-degree murder, they face the challenge of seating a new jury in a case that has already generated significant public scrutiny and online discourse.

Pending Court Logistics
Clancy, 36, remains in custody at a state hospital while awaiting the next phase of the legal process. The court has scheduled a hearing for December 30 to address trial logistics, including security and media arrangements.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why was the first trial declared a mistrial?
The judge declared a mistrial in September 2026 after the jury, consisting of nine women and three men, remained deadlocked after nearly 40 hours of deliberations. Eleven jurors had favored a verdict of not guilty by reason of insanity, while one juror dissented.
FULL STORY: Lindsay Clancy’s New Murder Trial Set for March 29: Prosecutors Stick With First-Degree Charges https://t.co/l0c6ZE7X6T
What is the defense’s primary argument regarding the killings?
Defense attorneys contend that Clancy was not criminally responsible for the deaths of her three children in January 2023 because she was suffering from severe postpartum psychosis. They assert she hallucinated a voice that ordered her to kill the children and herself. Prosecutors, conversely, argued that Clancy planned the killings and understood what she was doing.
Could Clancy avoid a second jury trial?
If prosecutors were to reduce the charges to second-degree murder or manslaughter, Clancy could potentially waive her right to a jury trial. In such a scenario, a judge would decide the verdict instead of a jury.
More on Lindsay Clancy
Related reading