The Rise of ‘Upgraded’ Begging: A Recent Trend in Southeast Asia
Kuala Lumpur and Johor Bahru are witnessing a concerning new trend: beggars donning elaborate costumes – from beloved cartoon characters like Super Mario and Doraemon to animals and dinosaurs – to solicit donations. This isn’t traditional panhandling. it’s a visually striking and increasingly sophisticated, form of begging that’s raising eyebrows and prompting calls for intervention from authorities.
Beyond the Costume: The Economics of Street Begging
The costumes themselves aren’t cheap. Reports indicate that similar outfits can cost between RM600 to RM1,000 (approximately $130-$220 USD). This investment suggests a calculated approach, moving beyond opportunistic begging to a more organized activity. Some beggars have even adopted digital payment methods, incorporating QR codes into their displays for direct bank transfers. A 61-year-old man, Kamal, reported earning up to RM100 (approximately $22 USD) within three hours, while a Rohingya woman, Sonny, claimed to collect between RM70 and RM100 in a similar timeframe.
Who is Behind the Mask?
What’s particularly troubling is the age of some of those involved. The article highlights instances of children as young as nine years old participating in this practice. A 14-year-old was observed taking selfies with tourists in a bunny costume. While some are driven by economic hardship – like Kamal, a retired cleaner supporting his ten children, or Sonny, a mother of twelve facing limited job opportunities – the involvement of minors raises serious concerns about exploitation and child welfare.
Territoriality and Risk
The situation isn’t without its challenges for those involved. Sonny reported being chased away by others for encroaching on established “territories,” suggesting a degree of competition and potentially organized control within this informal economy. Kamal acknowledged the risks, including weaving between traffic, but felt compelled to continue due to financial necessity. Despite these risks, he stated that police interactions have been limited to warnings.
Authorities Respond: Warnings and Pledges
Malaysian authorities are beginning to address the issue. Johor JKM (Social Welfare Department) hauled up three individuals in costumes for seeking donations at a traffic light, releasing them with warnings and requiring them to sign pledges against repeating the offense. Under the Destitute Persons Act, soliciting donations in public without a permit is prohibited. However, officials acknowledge that many involved are not vagrants but families struggling to make ends meet, necessitating cooperation with local authorities and police.
Future Trends: What’s Next for ‘Upgraded’ Begging?
This trend is unlikely to disappear quickly. Several factors suggest it could evolve and potentially spread to other regions.
Increased Sophistication
Expect to see even more elaborate costumes and interactive displays. The utilize of technology – QR codes, mobile payment systems – will likely become more widespread. Beggars may leverage social media to promote their locations or share stories to elicit sympathy and donations.
Expansion to New Locations
Currently concentrated in Kuala Lumpur and Johor Bahru, this practice could expand to other tourist hotspots, shopping centers, and transportation hubs throughout Southeast Asia. The visibility and perceived novelty of the costumes make them effective in attracting attention in crowded public spaces.
The Rise of ‘Branded’ Begging
We might see beggars aligning themselves with popular trends or events. For example, costumes related to current blockbuster movies or seasonal holidays could become common. This “branded” approach could increase donations by tapping into existing consumer interests.
Potential for Organized Crime
The investment in costumes and the reports of territorial disputes raise concerns about potential organized crime involvement. It’s possible that individuals or groups are coordinating these activities and profiting from the earnings of those in costumes.
FAQ
Is begging illegal in Malaysia? Yes, soliciting donations in public without a permit is prohibited under the Destitute Persons Act.
Are authorities doing anything to stop this trend? Yes, authorities are issuing warnings and requiring pledges against repeating the offense. They are too working with social welfare departments to address the underlying issues.
Why are people using costumes to beg? The costumes attract attention and elicit sympathy, potentially leading to increased donations.
Is it safe to deliver money to these beggars? Authorities advise against giving donations, as it encourages the practice and may not directly benefit those in need.
Did you know? A Labubu costume, similar to those being used by beggars, can cost upwards of RM600 (approximately $130 USD).
Pro Tip: If you want to help those in need, consider donating to reputable charities and social welfare organizations that provide long-term support.
What are your thoughts on this emerging trend? Share your opinions in the comments below. Explore our other articles on social issues and economic challenges in Southeast Asia for more in-depth analysis.
