Michelle Phan Faces Backlash Over AI-generated Anime Series

Beauty creator Michelle Phan faces criticism over her planned 50-episode anime series titled Kiss & Makeup, which appears to use artificial intelligence for its artwork.

Viewers have questioned whether aspiring artists could lose out on paid work in the project, Yahoo reported. The backlash centers on how the artwork is produced, with critics examining the reliance on automated tools.

“The comments are calling her out for it,” an anonymous Reddit poster wrote, according to Yahoo. “A guy called Andy who is a part of the project is defending the use of AI without fully saying it’s AI. funny how people will use AI but will dance around admitting it, just say it.”

Commenters questioned the value of watching a lengthy series if generated artwork replaced artists’ own work, Yahoo reported. One commenter saw a missed opportunity to give aspiring illustrators and animators paid work, while others felt the announcement put the episode count ahead of the artistic process.

Michelle Phan Faces Backlash Over AI-generated Anime Series
Photo: thecooldown.com

Critics of generative AI worry that training data may include copyrighted artwork used without permission. Beyond concerns regarding how these systems are trained, debates also persist around ownership, credit, and compensation when machine generation supplants paid animation and illustration tasks.

Yahoo reported that Phan established her audience via early YouTube makeup and transformation tutorials before branching into other commercial ventures. She co-founded the online beauty subscription service Ipsy in 2011. She also created The Enchantress, an online comic drawing on anime, manga, and fantasy art styles.

Michelle Phan's Planned Anime Kiss & Makeup Draws AI Criticism — AIPopDB

Phan’s involvement in illustrated narratives dates back prior to Kiss & Makeup. Fashion Times said that she discussed with Fast Company in 2015 how a story idea from her youth eventually blossomed into a comic venture, describing art and illustration as lifelong passions.

Kiss & Makeup is a planned 50-episode anime series announced by beauty creator Michelle Phan. The project has drawn scrutiny on Reddit over its use of artificial intelligence for artwork generation.

Viewers and Reddit commenters have questioned whether the project replaces paid work for human illustrators and animators. Critics have also raised broader concerns regarding copyright in AI training data and transparency about the production process.

Phan created an online comic titled The Enchantress, which draws on anime, manga, and fantasy art styles. In 2015, she said that art and illustration have been passions of hers since childhood.

Phan first built a following with makeup tutorials on Xanga and YouTube starting in 2007, and a viral Lady Gaga tutorial in 2009 helped her surpass one million subscribers. In 2010 Lancôme named her its first Vietnamese-American spokesperson, and in 2015 she appeared on the Inc. 30 under 30 and Forbes 30 under 30 lists after raising $100 million to value Ipsy at over $500 million.

She studied at Ringling College of Art and Design before leaving for financial reasons; the school later awarded her an Honorary Doctorate of Arts in 2014. Phan also launched the webtoon Helios: Femina in 2017 and voiced a character in the video game Cookie Run: Kingdom in 2021.

A Reddit poster asked why individuals working on the project seemed hesitant to directly admit whether they were using artificial intelligence. Commenters said that a clearer explanation of the production process, including which human artists are involved and what they contribute, would address these concerns.