The U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development issued a final rule on Nov. 10 that requires all members of households receiving federal rental assistance to verify their citizenship or eligible immigration status.
The policy, scheduled to take effect on Dec. 14, targets so-called “mixed-status” households where some members are eligible for federal subsidies and others are not.
Impact on New York Households
Current federal regulations allow families to live in subsidized properties, such as those overseen by the New York City Housing Authority, even if some members are ineligible for assistance.
These households currently pay a prorated rent rate to account for the ineligible individuals. The new rule would require proof of citizenship or qualified immigration status for every household member, a shift that advocates say could affect 2,500 families in New York alone.
“People can be in the United States lawfully, but they are not necessarily eligible for rental assistance under Section 214,” said Newman, who works with the Legal Aid Society. Newman said that three out of four members in these mixed-status households currently hold an eligible status, warning that the change could force eligible residents to move or separate from their families.
Did You Know? The federal government attempted to advance a similar policy in 2019, during President Donald Trump’s first term, but President Joe Biden later withdrew it.
Arguments Over Program Eligibility
HUD Secretary Scott Turner has described the rule as a measure to ensure only American citizens and certain eligible noncitizens reside in HUD-funded housing. According to a final rule announcement, the department aims to prioritize American citizens and eligible noncitizens for limited housing resources. The agency said that a prior audit identified nearly 200,000 tenants with incomplete or unknown eligibility verification.
Housing advocates, however, argue that the policy could increase costs for the federal program rather than save money. “It is actually more expensive to fund fully eligible households, because the subsidy has to cover all of the people in that household,” Newman said. Tran-Leung, who works with the National Housing Law Project, added that forcing these families out would reduce the overall supply of affordable housing.
Attorneys general and advocates consider legal options to block the rule
A coalition of 22 state attorneys general, including New York’s, previously expressed opposition to the rule in an April letter to HUD. Advocates are now considering legal options to block or delay the Dec. 14 implementation date. If the rule proceeds, tenants would have 90 days to provide documentation, though housing attorneys stress that residents maintain due process rights if a housing authority questions their status.
New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani said that the city is evaluating options to protect residents, while clarifying that there will be no immediate change to current subsidies. “The City is evaluating every available option to defend New Yorkers and protect their access to housing,” Mamdani said.
Which immigration statuses qualify for federal housing assistance?
Which immigration statuses are considered eligible for federal housing assistance?
Eligible statuses include green card holders, asylees, refugees, survivors of human trafficking, and self-petitioners under the Violence Against Women Act.
What happens to households that cannot provide documentation by the deadline?
Following the Dec. 14 effective date, residents would have 90 days to verify their status. Advocates emphasize that the process is not instantaneous and that residents retain due process rights if they are deemed ineligible.
How many people nationwide could be affected?
According to the Center for Budget and Policy Priorities, nearly 80,000 people across 20,000 households nationwide could be at risk of losing their homes. Of this group, 96 percent are people of color, including 86 percent who are Latino.
For now, residents are being urged to remain in their homes, as “until it goes into effect, nothing has changed,” according to Newman.
Related reading