New Yorker writers are reflecting on the past year by revisiting standout books from 2025. This is the second in a series of recommendations, with more to come in the weeks ahead. Readers seeking further reading can also consult the magazine’s annual list of the year’s best new titles.
Literary Recommendations for the New Year
The New Yorker has highlighted three books for readers this new year: George Plimpton’s “Out of My League,” Julia Langbein’s “American Mermaid,” and Willa Cather’s “Death Comes for the Archbishop.” Each offers a distinct reading experience, from participatory journalism to contemporary fiction and classic American literature.
Plimpton’s “Out of My League”
Writer Charles Bethea draws a connection between his own youthful attempts at comical failure—arm wrestling, archery, and a brief stint with elite marathon runners—and the work of George Plimpton. Plimpton’s 1961 book chronicles his experience floundering on the baseball field, building on a tradition of participatory sports journalism begun in 1922 by Paul Gallico.
Langbein’s “American Mermaid”
Rachel Syme recommends “American Mermaid” by Julia Langbein, published in 2023, as a standout literary novel. The story follows Penelope Schleeman, an English teacher whose feminist mermaid novel becomes a surprise bestseller, leading her into the often-absurd world of Hollywood adaptation. Langbein’s next novel, “Dear Monica Lewinsky,” is scheduled for release in April.
Cather’s “Death Comes for the Archbishop”
Willa Cather’s 1927 novel, “Death Comes for the Archbishop,” is highlighted for its evocative portrayal of the New Mexico territory. The story follows Father Latour, a French priest appointed bishop following the 1851 annexation, as he works to establish the diocese alongside Father Vaillant. The novel is noted for its exploration of the landscape and its potential homoerotic subtext.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the common thread between the three books recommended?
The three books, while different in genre and subject matter, all explore themes of immersion, challenge, and perspective—whether through direct participation, navigating a complex industry, or encountering a new and transformative landscape.
When was George Plimpton’s “Out of My League” originally published?
George Plimpton’s “Out of My League” was originally published in 1961.
What is Julia Langbein’s next novel about?
Julia Langbein’s next novel, “Dear Monica Lewinsky,” is about a woman who begins to pray to Monica Lewinsky as a secular saint and is scheduled for release in April.
What qualities do you look for when seeking out new book recommendations?
