Norwegian Court Rejects Nurse’s Vaccine Injury Compensation Claim

In a legal first for Norway, Frostating Court of Appeal concluded that an emergency room nurse diagnosed with ME after receiving a COVID-19 vaccine is not entitled to patient injury compensation.

Did You Know? Frostating Court of Appeal handled the case over three days in October, marking the first time an appellate court in Norway has ruled on a compensation claim regarding alleged adverse effects from COVID-19 vaccines.

Court Rejects Compensation Claim

The appellate court deliberated over three days in October before issuing its ruling. Justices determined it is not sufficiently probable that the nurse, referred to as Jon, developed the chronic fatigue condition as a direct result of the immunization.

Jon worked as a nurse at an emergency ward in Trøndelag and at an emergency medical communication center (AMK). In February 2021, he received the AstraZeneca vaccine against the virus.

“I got a strong reaction in the evening and I got really bad,” Jon said.

Fever, tremors, and chills subsided after a few days, but fatigue persisted in the following weeks. Months later, his health collapsed entirely, and following more than a year of medical investigations, he received an ME diagnosis in the spring of 2022. He currently receives work assessment allowance.

Majority and Minority Divide

The court split in its decision, with both the majority and minority agreeing that a causal link between the vaccine and the illness lacks sufficient probability. However, the judges disagreed on whether the vaccine holds any potential to cause such damage.

The majority acknowledged that the vaccine can potentially produce side effects such as ME. Still, the justices were not convinced that the immunization caused Jon’s specific illness, noting that roughly 10 weeks passed between the vaccination and the onset of severe symptoms.

Conversely, the minority, consisting of High Court Judge Ingvild Skaar, concluded that the vaccine cannot cause ME. The minority pointed out that hypotheses suggesting such a link lack adequate support in medical literature and studies, and emphasized that biomedical mechanisms governing CFS/ME remain largely unknown.

State Arguments and Legal Response

During the proceedings, state representative Christine Larsen Kalsvik argued that no practical possibility of a causal connection has been established. She said that billions of COVID-19 doses have been administered globally and over 14 million doses delivered in Norway without establishing an association with chronic fatigue.

Jon initially filed a claim with the Norwegian System of Patient Injury Compensation (NPE). After receiving a rejection, he brought a lawsuit against the state, and Trøndelag District Court concluded in February that the vaccine’s role was unproven.

Stian Henriksen, an attorney with the Norwegian Nurses’ Organisation who represented Jon, argued in court that public authorities should shoulder responsibility when doubt exists. Following the appellate decision, Henriksen stated in a text message that he and his client are familiar with the ruling and must review it thoroughly before deciding on further steps.

Frequently Asked Questions

When did Jon receive the vaccine and the diagnosis?

Jon received the AstraZeneca vaccine in February 2021 and received his ME diagnosis in the spring of 2022 following more than a year of medical examinations, according to Nrk.

How many vaccine doses have been administered in Norway?

State representatives noted during the trial that over 14 million doses of COVID-19 vaccines have been administered in Norway.

Frostating Court of Appeal traces its origins to the Frostating assembly created in the mid-10th century. The current court was established on 1 January 1890, dissolved in 1892, and re-established in its present form on 1 July 1936 with jurisdiction over Trøndelag and Møre og Romsdal. It sits permanently in Trondheim, Ålesund, Molde and Kristiansund and has 19 permanent judges.

Which court originally handled the dispute before the appeal?

Trøndelag District Court handled the initial lawsuit in February before the case was appealed to Frostating Court of Appeal.