NSW Coalition Faces One Nation Surge and Independent Challengers in North Shore Seats

As the New South Wales Coalition prepares for the March state election, independent candidates backed by community activists are threatening several heartland seats on Sydney’s north shore.

Independent Challenges on Sydney’s North Shore

The challenge comes as the NSW Coalition attempts to secure its right flank against a surging One Nation. This political pressure has prompted the Coalition to shift right on law and order, gun control, and climate policy, with the NSW Nationals abandoning climate targets entirely.

Former opposition leader Mark Speakman resigned from the Liberals on Thursday, joining a broader exodus of MPs who announced they will not contest their seats in March. Upon his resignation, he warned his party against becoming “One Nation lite.”

This shift to the right has created an opening for progressive independents in urban seats typically held by Liberal moderates. Amelia Loye, a management consultant specialising in stakeholder and community engagement, announced she is running in the seat of Willoughby.

“Willoughby has already shown it is ready for an independent,” Loye said, according to The Guardian. “Nearly half of voters backed one last time. I want to earn their support, and the support of those still deciding.”

Loye is backed by the community group Willoughby Votes, which secured 47% of the two-party preferred vote during the 2023 election. She attempts to unseat Liberal MP Tim James, who holds the seat on a 2.6% margin.

Did You Know? During the 2023 election, only 41% of One Nation voters nominated preferences, compared to 70% of Green voters and 49% of Labor voters, according to The Guardian.

As the coalition stares down one nation in nsw a threat
Photo: khanlist.com

Additional Contests and Regional Shifts

Other independent contenders include Elouise Massa, a small business owner running in the Sydney seat of Manly against Liberal Adelaide Cuneo. Massa entered the public eye after campaigning for the Northern Beaches hospital to return to public hands following her toddler’s death in emergency. Cuneo seeks to replace retiring MP James Griffin.

In North Shore, Mosman independent deputy mayor Michael Randall announced he will run as a community independent with support from figures behind former federal independent MP Kylea Tink’s campaign. Monica Wulff has also announced an independent run in Davidson.

Federal teal independents Sophie Scamps, Zali Steggall, and Nicolette Boele currently hold McKellar, Warringah, and Bradfield, respectively. Tink held North Sydney for one term before that federal seat was abolished.

A Liberal spokesperson defended the party’s position, stating, “We’ll keep making our case directly to voters, including why we oppose Labor’s gun buyback that targets law-abiding owners rather than criminals and terrorists.”

The Labor Premier’s Position

NSW Labor Premier Chris Minns has provided a political boost to some independents ahead of the vote. Minns joked that independent Jacqui Scruby—who won Pittwater at a byelection—should be known as “the member for Mona Vale road” due to her lobbying for infrastructure upgrades now being fast-tracked by the government.

NSW Coalition Faces One Nation Surge and Independent Challengers in North Shore Seats
Photo: finwire.io

Minns also appeared alongside Massa to praise her advocacy. Observers note that Minns is hedging his bets rather than embracing independents, as One Nation’s primary vote reaches as high as 30% in some polls and dims Labor’s prospect of increasing its majority in 2027.

Opposition leader Kellie Sloane has not ruled out a preference deal or post-election arrangement with One Nation, describing such options as hypothetical. However, analysts suggest such arrangements could alienate moderate Liberal voters and benefit progressive challengers.

Frequently Asked Questions

When is the New South Wales state election scheduled to take place?

The state election is scheduled for March.

Who is running against Liberal MP Tim James in Willoughby?

Management consultant Amelia Loye is running in Willoughby, backed by the community group Willoughby Votes.

What federal seats do teal independents currently hold in the region?

Federal teal independents Sophie Scamps, Zali Steggall, and Nicolette Boele hold the seats of McKellar, Warringah, and Bradfield, respectively.